St. Anger, 2003
Oof. OK, some background first. When Metallica was touring for the Black Album, James apparently went on an extended hunting trip in like Alaska or somewhere similarly cold and isolated. He said they basically spent a long time drinking in a snowed-in cabin and then hunting.
If you’ve never taken the time to read the lyrics that James has written over the years, the basics are that he had a fairly rough and traumatic upbringing. His Dad was not around very often, and his parents divorced in 1976, when he was 13. His Mom was a strict Christian Scientist who did not believe in medical care. She died when James was 16. James subsequently went to live with his older half brother. Dude had some shit happen to him, and music was his outlet. Kill ‘Em All came out when James was like 20-21 years old. And then Cliff died 3 years later.
24-25 year old kids in the spotlight of heavy metal, touring the globe and drinking a lot. Jason Newsted, Cliff’s replacement, sort of took on the role of the little brother that James could bully. It’s not… great. By about 2001, Jason had started to want to branch out, and he had a side project called “Echobrain” that he wanted to pursue while being in Metallica as well. James and Lars said nope, so Jason left. Good for him for picking his own musical growth over staying in what was essentially a very toxic environment for him, albeit with a lot of money.
James subsequently went into rehab for numerous drug addictions. He has a problem with alcohol in particular, and it was bad enough that James needed to get clean.
The band’s deal with record company, Elektra, was also coming to a close. Lars had also been arguing with the press about Napster and file sharing. In retrospect, Lars had some good points and it ultimately lead to a new era for the music industry.
Lots of shit going on in the background, lots of battles, and lots of internal strife.
So, now we get to the music on this record. It sucks. Critics have softened on it over the years. Before writing this, I tried to listen to the album again, and I just can’t do it.
The lyrical themes are drowned out by a bunch of songs that all kind of sound the same and seem to go on forever. Lars’ drumming is all pops and steel drums and then there are no choruses or guitar solos. They had no bassist so producer Bob Rock filled in on some of the tracks, and then they mixed the bass out of the songs in the production phase anyways.
My honest review is that it is hard to sit and listen to this album. It’s just not an enjoyable record.
In retrospect, I think this is the record that the band NEEDED to make, and it helped them as a group. It also lead to them finding Robert Trujillo, who is a natural fit as their bass player. They NEEDED to make it. I do NOT need to listen to it.
Lastly, I am only gonna pick only one track, and that’s because it sounds better live than I would have thought. They play “Frantic” live from time to time, usually with James asking the crowd if they want to hear anything from St. Anger, and the crowd uniformly roars back “NO!”. James laughs, and then plays “Frantic”, and it’s pretty good live.
I wish that St. Anger was Metallica’s worst album. It’s their second worst.
Really? Since St Anger is one of the two good albums Metallica made since... 1986 (the other one is the recent 2015 Hatdwired to Self-Destruct. So would be interested to hear your take what is their worst.
As someone who legimately hates guitar solos, in every 100 rock/metal songs with a guitar Solo it is outright useless at minimum 99 times, this was and still is one of the few Metallica records I listen.
Well, thanks man. I genuinely appreciate the rebuttal opinions on this stuff.
St. Anger is described online as having “Mixed to Positive” reviews. It’s got a 65% on allmusic.com
I made my feelings on it pretty clear, so it’s cool to hear from someone who genuinely likes this record.
As for Metallica’s worst record, I’ll get to Lulu in a bit.
I skipped S&M by mistake, so that’ll be next.