Y/N talking to Charlie: "So in Baldur's Gate 3,who did you romance because there were too many choices..."
Charlie: "Oh my God right!? I sat at the screen looking at everyone for days trying to decide."
Y/N: "I settled with the vampire and the large beefy Druid guy because let me climb you like a tree"
Dean taking notes
Sam: "Dude what are you doing?"
Dean: "Uh nothing... Why?"
Castiel: "I believe Dean is writing down what Y/N liked in a video game so he can be like that"
Dean glares at Castiel: "Maybe I'm coming up with Halloween costumes"
Y/N to Charlie: "Give me some flannel and a nice car and I'm good"
Dean smirking: "I'm back in! Take that video game men!"
Sam to Castiel: "He's hopeless"