i‘m pretty sure i‘m non-binary but in my country (or rather the region i live in) there isn‘t much known about it. as i feel most comfortable with he/him pronouns anway, would it still be okay to just say i‘m a trans man? i feel a little silly coming out in the first place so i want to make it „more understandable“ to my social bubble. (still unlearning transmedicalism)
Lee says:
As you know, it can be stressful to be in the closet! Being closeted can take a toll on your mental health because you constantly feel like you're hiding a part of who you are, and that can be tiring.
When you tell your friends that you're a trans man and don't disclose that you actually identify as a non-binary person, you're still closeted.
You're no longer hiding your trans identity and you can feel more comfortable expressing yourself as you are, so it may still be a relief, but you're still keeping something back, keeping something hidden, and passing yourself off as someone who you aren't.
I would encourage you to come out as non-binary to someone (or even multiple people, if you have multiple people) who you feel that you can trust.
If you're having difficulty accepting yourself as a non-binary person, having people around you who help affirm your identity can be very helpful; asserting your non-binary identity can also help you feel more valid because you're bringing it into your life and accepting it as part of who you are.
Claiming your non-binary gender is especially important for someone who is still unlearning transmedicalism for that reason.
While I do believe that coming out as non-binary is a good idea, I recommend doing so with several caveats. Coming out is often a necessary step in our transition journey, but it is true that many people do not accept trans folks and do not believe that non-binary people even exist.
Coming out and subsequently facing rejection from those around you can have an even larger toll on your mental health than being closeted does; while you're no longer hiding who you are, you may be facing an increase in transphobic rhetoric and harassment, or even physical violence.
I always tell people to stay closeted if they don't think that it's safe to come out. If someone is a minor (or otherwise dependent on a person) who may physically or emotionally abuse them, they should wait to come out until they have a safety plan in place and are ideally more independent and able to survive without the financial/logistical support of their guardian/caregiver.
There are many gradients between coming out to a dangerous parent who is likely to abuse you and coming out to a friend who will be a jerk about it; sometimes it is worth coming out to people who may not accept you because it will allow you to surround yourself with only those who actually support you, and it may even help educate someone who wasn't as familiar with the trans community and make them more accepting.
All that being said, I do believe that sometimes it's okay to be 'closeted' about being non-binary even when you're out as transgender! You're not letting down the non-binary community if you don't always shout that you're non-binary from every rooftop.
Being out as non-binary is often more difficult than being out as a binary trans person in places with a very binary culture. That's a controversial statement, but I do genuinely believe it to be true if you control for other factors such as gender expression and the ability to pass as cisgender.
I don't think that you need to shoulder the burden of educating your entire region on non-binary identities; sometimes it's just easier to let people think that you're a binary trans guy, if that's something that they understand and maybe even accept, instead of explaining what it means to be non-binary and then having to defend the existence of your gender.
If you think that there are some people, like causal acquaintances, classmates, or colleagues, who may not understand or accept non-binary identities, and who you don't really care to 'show the real you' to, then you should feel free to go ahead and let them think that you're binary.
I don't think you owe anyone an explanation of your gender identity; you're not a bad person for telling people that you're a trans man when you're actually non-binary.
It's not a moral/ethical issue to present only part of your identity to others because you're afraid of facing discrimination; you're not pretending to be a trans man to get something that you don't deserve. Everyone deserves support and acceptance and understanding.
As folks who have followed our blog for a while may know, I personally identify as genderqueer and use they/them pronouns, and I'm out as non-binary to all of my friends and family. But I use he/him pronouns at work and am 'closeted' to my boss as a binary trans man instead of 'out' as a non-binary person. I'm also recently post-transition which has allowed me to be 'stealth' at work when I'm interacting with coworkers or patients, so I sometimes don't come out as transgender at all, and let people assume that I'm a cisgender man.
I don't think it's a necessary use of my time or energy to explain that I'm non-binary to my grandparent's neighbors, but I do want my partner to know that part of me because it's something that forms who I am.
I present different facets of my gender to different people in my life, depending on how often I interact with them, how much they mean to me, and how comfortable I am with them. So I am not judging you because I literally do the same thing!
But it can be valuable to come out as non-binary to at least some of the people who you are the closest to, whether that's your partner, best friends, supportive aunt, or another meaningful person in your life.
That doesn't mean that you have to come out as non-binary to them right away if you're not ready for it, but it is something that you should consider doing at some point in the future.
It's not all-or-nothing, or like you have only one chance to come out; it's possible to tell some of your friends that you're a binary trans man and then tell them that you're actually non-binary a couple of months later!
It is true that rapidly switching your label may make some people think that you aren't confident about your identity and that it may be a passing fad that you'll get over, but over the years they should see that it's something that you are sticking with.
And even if it does turn out to be a passing phase for you, that's okay too-- you don't need to know every element of who you are yet.
You might be "pretty sure" that you're non-binary today, but find out that you're actually [insert other label] in another 6 months, and if that happens, you need to accept it without being ashamed or embarrassed about 'getting it wrong' the first time. You have a whole life ahead of you, and there's plenty of time to figure out what label you like the best.
When I came out as a cisgender lesbian at age 13 I never would have thought that I'd be identifying as a genderqueer transsexual at age 23. I didn't even know that non-binary people existed then, and when I found out that being non-binary was a possibility for people it took me a while to unlearn by internalized transphobia and accept that it's not only a valid identity but also one that actually applies to me!
So yeah, I've changed labels more than once and that isn't a bad thing! I learned more about myself in the process. My transition wasn't a straight line from A to B--- nothing about me is straight! I went through an evolution as I figured out who I was, and that's a natural part of growing up.
I wish you the best in your coming out journey, whatever path you choose to take, regardless of whether you tell folks that you're non-binary or a guy. Do whatever makes you the most comfortable, and don't be ashamed of who you are. Easier said than done, yes, but with time, therapy, and surrounding yourself with a supportive community, it is possible to be accept yourself.
Followers, any advice on unlearning transmedicalism and accepting yourself for anon?