Damn, you picked a heavy one. I’ve actually been feeling bad lately about the fact that I don’t seem to hold onto friends terribly long. I’m not still friends with a single person I knew in high school (Facebook doesn’t count), and recently when I found myself in a sticky situation and had to beg for help online, the two people who offered are new friends from the last six months or so.
One of my best friends in high school was Ellie (names changed because otherwise it’s a bit weird). We continued to hang out a ton in college, but then lost touch when we both moved out of state (pre-social networking, natch). Then we both moved back to Seattle around the same time, and started hanging out again. We ended up living together for a year, and became incredibly close again. We had a little group made up of us, her boyfriend Jack, his coworker Ray (currently one of my best friends), and another girl named Maggie. We called ourselves the Muffins, and we did just about everything together: played RockBand on a weekly basis, went camping every summer, spent a week together in New Orleans for Ellie and Jack’s wedding. But after maybe four years, Ellie and I started drifting apart. She and Maggie became closer, and eventually she and I had a fight I don’t remember any more, the sort of fight that isn’t about what it’s about, but is a culmination of a lot of other feelings. Ellie said she needed some space from me, and I gave it to her. We just never came back from that. She and Jack sort of drifted away from Ray too, and eventually split up. Maggie moved away. Eventually Ellie and I took a stab at being friends again and went out for lunch a few times to catch up, but it just didn’t take. Whatever had connected us so strongly, at two different times in our lives, was gone.