Jennifer's Body au
-Eddie as Jennifer, Waylon as Anita, Lisa as Chip.
-a bit of a twist tho, just like the movie, Eddie and Waylon are bestfriends since childhood when Waylon understands Eddie doesn't have the best home life. But Eddie (despite being a major playboy and major closeted boi), has strong feelings for Waylon and they're actually soul mates,and thats why Eddie can't seduce Waylon or hurt him.
-can't decide if Waylon ends up killing Eddie not.
-the band that preys on Eddie is called Murkoff ((lead singer Jeremy Blaire))
-instead of just making out, Waylon and Eddie have a saucy night, Eddie appearing befote Waylon, solemn and Waylon asks what's wrong ((never a car incident)), Eddie explains he can feel Waylon no matter where he goes and Eddie asks if its the same for Waylon. Waylon remembers flashes of visions when he was Lisa before he rushed home from these "hallucinations".
-Seeing Waylon's distraught look, Eddie starts caressing him and one thing leads to another. Its only afterward that Eddie reveals his true nature that he's becoming something more than human and explains he killed someone to sustain himself.
-of course at this point Waylon demands him to leave. The next days, Eddie is almost deliberately ignoring Waylon or is really unnoticing of Waylon after their nught together. Waylon meanwhile looks longingly from a far and can't come face to face with Lisa and ultimately breaking up with her because of it and for her safety.