Imagine Dr. Lombardi sending the She-Creature to off you, but she’s way more interested in spawning. 

Note: Obscure monster girl. 

Imagine Thomas Wake mistaking you for a mermaid. 

Imagine Jellica deciding you’ll be her mate.

In the Sea Overlord’s grip, you steeled yourself for the venomous sting. Which never came. Instead, tendrils tenderly rubbed your shoulders and neck.

“Let us make larvae.”

“Isn’t that something you can do by yourself?”

“Oh, I am feeling rather medusoid right now,” Jellica purred, removing your helmet. A tentacle caressed your cheek.

It was flattering to be considered attractive by a mermaid, albeit such an unconventional one. Unconventionally attractive popped into your mind. Still, having a mouthless, noseless woman nuzzle your nape was disconcerting.

But, her jellified form encasing you, that gloved hand cupping your jaw, tentacles resting on your clavicle… How would she feel with nothing between you?

“Fertilize my eggs, ______.”

Her command solidified your choice. Jellica’s embrace loosened. So you turned around.

Mermen Characters

Note: To celebrate MerMay. This list is includes ones based on cephalopods, coral, crustaceans, pinnipeds, seaweed, etc. Basically any type of fishy or marine life humanoid. (Or water life in general.) I plan to update this. Be free to suggest more! 

Imagine after you resist her seduction attempts, the mermaid hypnotizes you with her singing.

Imagine the mermaid trying to lure you into her tub during her spawning time.

Imagine doing some late night swimming with Elly that ends with some pearl diving.