mouthporn.net
#rwde – @sytokun on Tumblr
Avatar

SWITCHBACK

@sytokun / sytokun.tumblr.com

SYTO ◆ mainly art and rwby ◆ rwde posts are tagged
Avatar

"You're just an animator, you have no idea how story arcs or character works" Damn, what does that say about the people whose actual job description says "Writer" then?

These and braindead "Monty himself said he was never a good writer" takes pisses me the fuck off. A guy acknowledged his forte is in animation and he's not as confident at writing and you clowns take that as OBJECTIVE FACT and blame all the bad writing on him while absolving the bad writing from his collaborators written after his passing just to blame him posthumously, god

Avatar

To anyone thinking or saying Dillon Goo is unworthy of acquiring RWBY, not because of anything realistic like finances or the size of his studio, but because he's "just an animator", or just a rando from the internet who cannot write or run RWBY:

Thanks for perpetuating the piece of shit mindset that every soul-sucking corporation and braindead consumer has: that animators have no value or are just there to push buttons and make pixels move for the real creatives.

Animators are artists and creators. They have to work with numerous departments to make things work: They have to know what the writer/director wants, and tell them if it's even possible to put to screen; they have to work with artists and character designers to tell if they can commit that art into moving parts. And for an animated show, they're kind of... I dunno, the entire backbone of its production.

Anyone stupid enough to claim that, by their logic, should claim that Miles and Kerry were "just writers" and don't have the right nor the intelligence to have any opinions on RWBY's animation, character designs or music. That's how I know you have zero fucking idea how any actual media is produced, because in your head, these positions all just exist as separate little boxes in your brain so it's simple enough for you to grasp.

It was "just an animator" who made RWBY in the first place, dumbass. A "rando" making animations on the internet that Rooster Teeth took a chance on, and now he's responsible for their best-selling IP. By comparison, Dillon is starting at a way better starting position than Monty was, with a successful YouTube channel, public support from multiple current and ex-CRWBY like J Grelle (Tyrian's VA), Kim Newman (former animator who animated Sun's gunchucks in V5) and Jessica Nigri (Cinder's VA), and multiple collaborations with big companies like Hoyoverse.

If anything, I'd expect an animator like Dillon to know and care enough about his staff to not give them near-irreparable spinal damage. Gee, I wonder why Newman would think he'd be a better employer to work with? Dillon would know how an animation project is run and budgeted. Him being an animator is a benefit, for god's sake.

Monty had character design sketches but needed help from professional artists to fully design them. He knew bits of the plot but needed help fleshing it out. Do you have enough brain cells to rub together to know that's precisely what Dillon can do, too? Fuckin', I dunno, hire people? For his studio??

I'd rather have an animator run RWBY because RWBY is an animated series and he would know precisely 1) what complements the medium best and 2) the precise limits of what can or cannot work within his budget. By your ass-backwards logic, I would rather get EC Myers to run RWBY's production over Dillon just because he's a writer and has been employed with RT longer.

That's another moronic argument: "He's only been employed by RT for 1 Volume". Man, I don't care if he's been there for zero Volumes, his work clearly shows a greater understanding of RWBY's aesthetic, mainstream appeal and style than its own showrunners have for the past 7 years. Or is seniority in a defunct company responsible for a steadily unprofitable IP suddenly a positive in this business deal?

I need you to be aware that RWBY as an IP is a joke outside of the bubble of its fandom, and I am telling you bluntly as a fan. Nobody takes it seriously and the ones that do only praise it for either its action choreography or its character designs, one of which is guaranteed with Dillon's studio. Diehard fans may love RWBY, warts and all, but all that love and support clearly wasn't enough to keep it alive, because its reputation was already cemented from its own mismanagement.

What you do is you get the right person for the job. And Dillon ticks a lot of boxes for it. If you think he's unable to acquire RWBY because he's not a big corpo or cannot meet Warner's asking price, that's 100% fair. If you think he's unable to create something on the scale of Volume 9, that's also 100% fair, but only if you're attached to the idea that you'd rather have Volume 10 or more of the same RWBY that was operating at a loss than any RWBY at all. Or if you'd rather see a season of 14 episodes 15 minutes long where 60-70% of it is made up of exposition, talking head scenes and increasingly overambitious world expanding, over shorter episodes with amazing RWBY action sequences with a story that never bites off more than it can chew.

But if you think Dillon is unqualified or worse, unworthy or undeserving (what a weirdo thing to say about a person, like owning RWBY is like inheriting the fucking throne of Gondor), all because he's "just an animator" or because he was smart enough to see RT for the meat-grinder hellhole it was and left to find success on his own, you're full of shit.

And if you disapprove of him because of his association with Shane, go find a restroom because your unsightly hateboner is showing. It's been almost ten years since the letter and you all have been holding this unfettered rage clenched between your buttcheeks longer than Shane's ever been with Rooster Teeth.

And for what? Pointing out Rooster Teeth is a fucked place to work at? Whoops, that was true and now it's six feet under for every scandal and worker abuse case they brought on themselves. For stealing and cannibalising their creators' IPs? Whoops, that's fucking true as well.

Avatar

I love coming across random Tumblr posts from the same 6 people in Canonseeker's social circle still bringing up "tea" nobody cares about

My Yang redesigns (2018 & 2021):

The actual ass show (2023):

My dude her boobs are as big as her whole ass head. I guess RWBY is being animated by incel shitbags too? Or is that ok since their boots are tastier?

It's ok to admit you know jack shit about anything you're talking about, being terminally online and locked in a parasocial hellhole with an apathetic company has that effect on you

Avatar
reblogged
Avatar
rwbycritblog

The whole idea that it’s we, the watchers of RWBY, who are wrong for not supplying the show with the things they didn’t show, (”The writers are trusting you to know that obviously the characters are training and growing off-screen,” “Obviously Yang told everyone what actually happened with Raven off-screen, so everyone who’s saying that she lied are really just watching in bad faith,” “RWBY doesn’t have to show you characters connecting or talking to each other, it’s obvious that they’re super close anyway,” “The characters aren’t underdeveloped, you just don’t want to look at what’s there and build on that,” “What people don’t understand is that RWBY is a slow burn,” “What people don’t understand is that RWBY is Hope!Punk,” ect. ect.) is kind of a wonky way of thinking. 

Like sure, there’s a suspension of disbelief, but put enough weight on that, and the whole thing falls apart. 

The thing that snags me on this like the paper towel from the Last Day of Summer episode of Phineas and Ferb is that it’s an open admission that there are things that you need to know in order for the show to make sense, and it’s not there

It feels like RWBY was a TV show adaptation of a book franchise that a lot of people didn’t read, and everyone who is telling us that we’re purposely missing things that aren’t ever shown to us, have read all of the hypothetical books that we haven’t and are telling us that if we read the books, everything would make sense, but the books were never written. 

This isn’t even the MCU relying on the audience to not only watch all of their films in order to know anything about what’s happening and also to watch the Agents of Shield TV show, because RWBY doesn’t have info-dumps in a spin-off TV show. (There’s an unrelated book series which I won’t pay money to read because I’m broke and I haven’t looked for a free way to read it because I don’t want to read punching bag!Sun)

Listen, the first DC movie I ever watched was the 2017 Justice League movie. It was terrible for first time viewers. Apparently, it was terrible for DC fans too, but this isn’t about that. I struggled to know who some of the characters were, there was like, a fifteen minute montage at the start of the film about how everyone missed and needed Superman, there were weird one-liners from the characters, everyone was underdeveloped and disconnected from their actual mission, there were onscreen deaths of characters that I didn’t know, and weird allusions to things that I’m confident were from past movies, but I didn’t have the necessary knowledge to watch a hyped up box-office mainstream movie, because I didn’t know my homework. 

And I genuinely think that that’s better than RWBY because at least it was written down somewhere.

My point is, the writers of RWBY need to do their own work and write their own story instead of relying on their audience to write it themselves while still being the ones to make all the money. 

Avatar
reblogged
Anonymous asked:

Would you do anything about Yang & Blake's "conflict" after v3, or would you remove it entirely?

I think the issue with the show is that the show did remove it.

The show basically completely forgot that those two characters have their own story arcs AND that there's unresolved issues between them. After the show reunites RWBY team, all that the narrative does is lip-service. Be it with the issues between Blake and Yang OR even just overall Yang's own abandonement issues and trauma (Raven story arc was laughably bad and the narrative feels outright ashamed to actually acknowledge that Yang lost an arm.)

One of the many things that I was in disbelief about when the team reunion happened was how it literally did not address any of the issues the team members would now have with each other. It's like Team RWBY split up to go shopping or something. How could and would the team just be back together without addressing ANY of elephants in the room?

I think its crucial to address the situation at the end of V3 because its basically the only way to properly delve into Yang's bigger abandonement issues, why she is the way she is and so on. Abandonement and self-doubt has been core of Yang since, well, ever.

Its also crucial for Yang and Blake's relationship. The foundation IS there but without actually parsing their emotional grievances and issues and developing them, you can't build any sort of relationship or bond there. Blake running away is something that is CRUCIAL to BOTH characters and should affect both of them. They are bound by a traumatic and horrifying event and neither character should be able to truly move forward in the story, both as people and yeah even as a pairing, without addressing those issues.

Yang was unable to protect someone she wanted to protect, she was unable to protect her sister from getting traumatized, the entire world might be thinking of her as this random unstable weirdo who broke some guy's leg on live tv. And now Blake just left without saying a word. And then Ruby went off on her big journey without a single warning either. She is left there alone, her life in pieces, to deal with both physical and psychological trauma. What does all of that make Yang feel about herself? She is absolutely the kind of person who would go "What did I do wrong? Why am I not good enough?".

Its a PERFECT moment for some good ol' soul-searching and you just can't do that without addressing the issues between characters along the way.

I am of firm belief that the show should have NEVER moved forward with all the Gods and Relics nonsense without doing that first. Then again, the show preferably should have never had the nonsensical gods subplot in the first place.

There's enough going on in the world of Remnant as is.

Avatar
Avatar
sytokun

You actually bring up a very good point that the transition from V3 to V4 presented a really good foundation to explore each girl's deep struggles.

Yang with her being abandoned and not being able to protect her friends, when so much of her revolves around being a stable rock for her family and to an extent her team.

Blake with forcing herself to isolate herself from her found family to distance her past from them now that it's caught up to her in the worst way possible.

Ruby's hero complex going through the roof after losing at least two close friends and her team, and so feeling like she has to do everything she can to "fix" things and rush headlong into danger again without really considering her team.

Weiss too, since she was trying to get away from her family the whole time only to get dragged back home through circumstances out of her control, when autonomy was all she's seeking for.

And to the show's credit, it did feel like they intended to explore these themes by showing the different girls' POVs throughout V4-5, it just could've used a good pass or two to really nail these themes home in the minute execution.

Avatar
reblogged
Avatar
saltedsnails

At an alarming frequency online I’m seeing a lot of people just going the fuck off about critics of RWBY, so let me apparently say this again:

If you feel personally attacked because people don’t like your “thing,” you have an issue. And it’s your issue to deal with. Yours. You are equating your self worth with the things you enjoy, and you’re taking it personally when people rightfully call out extremely pertinent issues that need attention brought to them. Telling people to stop criticizing what you enjoy is going to do the opposite, and then you’re going to be more upset. Crusading against critics is pointless. Perhaps seeking the answer as to why you take criticism over an animated show so seriously would help you as an individual.

- 🐌

Avatar
reblogged

Hey crazy thought, but what if V10 simply isn't happening and RT's goal is to keep RWBY in this liminal space between volumes in the eyes of the fandom to keep taking their money? Like so much of the talk surrounding the upcoming movie is "We have to watch it legally and support RT to get V10", but that wouldn't be happening if people knew V10 wasn't happening, and they can do this for a while. Get this streaming service to get V10, buy this merch to get V10, Venmo RT money directly to get V10, they could keep the grift going at least a few years.

Avatar
sytokun

Blizzard: "Hey, actually Overwatch 2's PvE campaign was already scrapped by the time we announced the game, but how about we say it's there anyway and lead you on a trail of false hope so you continue supporting the franchise we're holding at gunpoint, in the promise of a product you may or may not ever get?"

Rooster Teeth:

Avatar
reblogged
Avatar
oddlyhale

It always feels like the show will do anything to protect Jaune, that's my honest opinion.

Even when he and Team RWBY are trapped on this other universe where they can do nothing but talk or yell at each other - with no Ironwood punching bag around - Jaune cannot be confronted with killing Penny.

You can't tell me, "Ruby has a good heart and wouldn't do that," even though she was ripping into her team before Jaune came in hot with yelling back at her. She would've thrown Penny's death back in his face.

If anything, if there was one person wouldn't be mad at, it would be Weiss. Because at least Weiss told them the truth, meanwhile Jaune is keeping his lips locked and never saying anything until it's screaming in his face to confess.

The universe needs to bend in every which way to make sure Jaune is never faced with what he did and how it hurts others, not just hurting himself.

Avatar
reblogged

Honestly the biggest disservice is making Blake into rules and law now. Like the girl was a fucking rebel and a punk. She was a law-breaking criminal and when she wasn't hurting innocent people, she didn't mind it!

She has made jokes about it - to Terra Cotta-Arc even!

Why in the FUCK does she care about breaking the rules of Ever After? WHY? Why is she so "we must follow the rules"? It makes no sense to any other part of her character. Is it just because someone had to be responsible if Ruby is off being depressed?

SHE AND YANG TOLD ROBYN SO MUCH SHIT AGAINST RULES AND ORDERS. WHY DOES SHE CARE NOW?

Also all of them know this is just a fucking fairytale location. So why is Blake so "Oh god if we fuck up we're fucked". The cuts in V9 weren't just to the detriment of the setting and character arcs, they just make all the characters act like idiots.

Avatar
sytokun

If you treat Blake as a bookworm though, then it kinda makes sense, in the sense of someone who's so worn down and sick of real life that they have vastly more respect for fictional worlds and its internal consistency, which is lowkey relatable so I'm kind of here for it lol. But that's really the only context I can see it working.

Avatar
reblogged
Avatar
psyga315

You are a broken fucking record, IAmAFanOfCartoons/CanonSeeker/Whatever else you want to be fucking called because people keep ousting you like the plague you are.

All Syto did was edit out this.

(well, and another similar shot)

And like clockwork, you're going on and on and on about how people who don't sing high praises about Bumblebee are the worst kinds of people imaginable, to the point where you're just repeating yourself over and over and over and over and over again.

This is why I'm christening you with a new nickname: FNDM-GPT. Because at this point, an anon message will just give you a prompt and you will spit out a canned response like a chatbot.

Keep this up and we'll likely be replacing RWBY fans with tech like you in the next 6-8 months.

Avatar
sytokun

I find it hilarious that the only takeaway they have from my edit is "Blake and Yang were edited out, clearly SYTO hates them". The edit in question btw.

Um, no. If anything, all my edits were done to portray Team RWBY in as good a light as possible. Removed all shots of Blake and Yang acting like helpless bystanders, when they're trained combatants who are supposed to be in perfect sync with Ruby. Having them offscreen would be preferable to making them look this uncoordinated.

And removed the shot of Ruby flailing and screaming through the air because this show loves forgetting its one unique trait in all of fiction (but does barely anything with that golden idea) of using weapons fire and recoil to completely trivialise falling, i.e. Ruby just looks incompetent. I made the characters look better as a net positive and you blockheads think I hate them, for fuck's sake.

"Yang and Blake are just in shock/concerned"

Yeah, I remember this same nothing argument when they were all standing around watching Ruby drink the tea as well, or Ruby being unable to save Yang from falling in V8. For an action series, it sure relies a lot on inaction to function. Call the bad direction/editing for what it is, please. God forbid I want the characters to act at the same level of competence and situational awareness they did in their very first trailers ten years ago.

Tell me it wouldn't be more in-character for Yang to immediately rush in upon seeing Ruby in danger fighting a Grimm by herself. Tell me Blake can't just use her shadow clones or Gambol Shroud to grab Ruby or get up to her. This generic "stand around gasping" reaction being applied to all the characters is exasperating and erases any unique reaction or agency they would have in the scene. And if they're not supposed to enter the scene because it's not in the script/too much work? Just fuckin' cut them out, you literally lose nothing from having them be offscreen and the focus be on Weiss helping Ruby.

Also note that Canonseeker is a fucking scumbag and nothing they say should ever be taken with an ounce of seriousness given their history across the RWBY fandom and their complete willingness to impersonate and misrepresent me in the worst ways possible.

Avatar
reblogged
Avatar
dragynkeep
Anonymous asked:

Can I just say how wild it is how many unintentional narrative thrulines they put for Ladybug in this goddamn show. Like how are you gonna have the Beauty/Beast analogy not connect to the Rose, especially with the immediate parallel of Adam having 'wilt' and all of Ruby's rose allusions are about growing/blooming. How Blake's trailer ends on black petals over red, while Ruby's petal burst is red over black. A silver/gold eye scheme, literal light(silver eyes)/darkness(from shadows), Ruby being the hope Blake once thought Adam was HOW DO YOU WRITE ALL OF THIS UNINTENTIONALLY-

they wrote one of the greatest potential love stories accidentally & it all could've began with ruby being the first person to come to blake & blake letting ruby be the first one she canonically opens up to. i'm gnawing at my goddamn walls

Avatar
Avatar
reblogged
Anonymous asked:

do you think some rwby characters have been unfortunately unitentionally turned to mary sues/gary stus

Jaune. Jaune. Jaune.

Perfectly describes Jaune and I don't even know if unintentionally.

We started with an okay set-up - a screw up with all the wrong ideas about "being heroic" and all the insecurities about his masculinity learning to be his own person and learning to express himself is actually a pretty strong starter premise for a character. But at some point that turned into "a burdened man learning to be the HERO through SUFFERING and DYING WOMEN as everyone gets to understand his PAIN and how much he DIDN'T ASK FOR THIS"

The writers kind of...forgot that he isn't the protagonist and just a side-character? And then kind of gave him ALL the screentime and ALL the plotlines and ALL the importance.

SOMEHOW Jaune feels like both a self-insert OC, Author's Pet AND yet somehow also blank slate at the same time.

  • As far as Fanfic OC aspect goes, Narrative will ALWAYS find an excuse of just WHY Jaune should absolutely be involved in something. It's almost like plot can't be allowed to progress with him. There's a "slight"(understatement) change in how he is written after the first three Volumes in that the narrative intent is to frame him as the inspiring one, the heroic one, the one that comes up with various ideas and the one that is the "heart" of the story. Ironically that's also pretty common with fanfic OC self-inserts being added, as the first thing a person usually does is to try to find a reason on just why the character matters and why the character sticks with the "cool kids(original protagonists)". Maybe the protagonists have an issue, but the OC is there to come up with a solution?! Maybe the OC had a very sad past that he shares with the protagonists showing how much the whole situation thematically is about him too?! Maybe the OC has a History with one of enemies that makes them motivated to defeat them (so what if often the fanfic OC's "history/motivations" ends up overlapping with actual story protagonist's reasons to want to fight the said antagonist) - pretty often involving a dead LI. Suddenly its the OC who is having this journey while the protagonists of the story are along for the ride and are affected by his growth and actions.
  • As far as Author's Pet goes, the narrative will ALWAYS self-congratulate itself on Jaune's growth and progress and how much of a bigger-person he is in spite of all his Flaws(tm) and in spite of how much he "didn't ask for this". Let's say it again, but bit more bluntly - In a story where the main message just now was that trauma and flaws don't matter and the protagonist is flawless and psychological trauma isn't real, the narrative will STILL self-congratulate itself over Jaune's growth over...his flaws and trauma?! There's pretty clear-cut subconscious element to the character writing too as Jaune is the inexperienced youngster who is thrust into the role of leadership and is reluctantly leading the narrative forward, in spite of everyone (especially villains!) telling him of how he is not a hero and how this is a hard path to walk. He is overwhelmed by the responsibility but perseveres through all the loss and tragedy to inspire others and all other characters recognize his growth and note how much stronger and mature he is now and how he's wise now. Even if we ignore the absolutely clear-cut (un)intentional metaphor of "just two inexperienced white guys writing this huuuuge show" as Miles would likely put it, There's an intent behind the narrative to try to make him likeable. In fact there's more intent in trying to make JAUNE likeable than literally any other character in the story including the ACTUAL protagonists. The narrative DESPERATELY wants the audience to see him as the "heart of the story". The story by all means shouldn't be about Jaune or relating to Jaune or telling us how Jaune feels but the narrative absolutely bends over backwards to make it so. Which gets ESPECIALLY ridiculous when the writers try to find a reason to put Jaune together with the PROTAGONISTS in their Filler Character Development Goof Dimension.
  • Which leads to the blank slate part, because since narrative is trying extra hard to make the audience relate to Jaune's "just a normal guy" status, intentionally or unintentionally, the character does fit the "audience self insert" idea too - Jaune is written as non-descript enough for the audience to self-insert into him ( and the show actually manages to make him MORE non-descript in terms of appearance somehow), he is surrounded by all these larger than life characters (most of them women) telling him how much he has grown and travelling with him. Even villains(most of them women) focus on him and he gets to save others and tell others how much its all about him and his emotions and struggle. Sure there's trauma (that's fine because people inserting can just ignore it, like they always do), but there's also no lasting negative consequences for his actions so the audience doesn't feel bad about relating to him too much. Sure the premise started with him having flaws but "he changed" and there's no real effort to examine the consequences or meaning behind his actions or character tropes. If one didn't say the name of the actual show, the whole set up would be pretty close to a cheap light novel premise.

The sad part is I genuinely couldn't tell you if all of that is the writers of MilesWBY being THAT self-indulgent intentionally or if parts of it are just an unintentional result of bad writing.

Avatar
Avatar

If yang is treated like an awful sister in volume 9 and her paying attention to blake and ignoring ruby is treated as a flaw and was called out for said flaw how you feel about that?

Avatar

I think in general, I completely agree with the people calling Yang an awful sister in Volume 9. I've heard every defense imaginable for why she was acting the way she was acting in V9, but really, Ruby's growing breakdown and her suffering was obvious. Like Ruby quite literally fainted from her trauma, and went through almost the whole volume in uncharacteristic gloom while showing complete disinterest in trying to get back her once beloved weapon, only having small two second moments of happiness here and there that quickly got crushed, being self-deprecating, hunching in on herself, trying not to fall apart, and then she had a panic attack during the fight with Neo's Jabberwalkers at the Paper Pleaser's village, and.... Yang was doing what? Not noticing.

Giggling and flirting, and smarting off and rolling her eyes, and having a grand old time in her fights, and dismissing it when Ruby did start to talk about her regrets by saying it's like Ironwood. Yeah, Yang shows some minor concern sometimes before Ruby's breakdown, but to me it felt like less concern than one of my coworkers had shown one time that I was sick at work and they had to drive me home. It didn't feel like the care a good older sister would show to a traumatized and clearly struggling beloved younger sister, it felt like the passing obligatory sympathy a stranger would show to another stranger if they found them crying at a bar. Like 'Oh are you okay? Yeah? Okay, if you're sure. I'll get back to my friend group.' And then you just move on and try to have fun for the rest of the night. That's how Yang prior to Ruby's breakdown feels to me.

Then while Ruby's having her breakdown, what does Yang do?

Yang 1. treats Ruby like a threat to Blake and glares at her. 2. does absolutely nothing to console Ruby or protest her words in any way. 3. does absolutely nothing when Jaune starts yelling in her face victim blaming her for things outside of her control and essentially saying she's not allowed to feel bad things or express that she feels bad things while she's standing there crying. 4. Doesn't immediately run after her when she takes off alone in a dangerous chaos world after she just demonstrated that she might not be able to fight, is clearly emotionally compromised, and being actively targeted by Neo who just made it even more clear that she's gunning directly for Ruby. 5. Gets angry like "how could she be kinda mean to me? Why couldn't she talk to me even though I shot her down the one time she expressed negative feelings to me? Ugh she's so impossible, not being one hundred percent okay after the death of her friend and being upset that I'm treating this like a romantic fun getaway while she's spiraling into an obvious breakdown that I didn't notice at all."

And then when Ruby ascends, Yang is like beaming away hugging Jaune like five minutes later? And when she sees Ruby in the tree, she's at least somewhat affected - although still much less than I'd want her to be, like compare Yang seeing Ruby in the tree to when the Doctor in Doctor Who thought he lost Rose for the first time, or Jack Harkness when Rose "dies" in front of him (since they didn't even know each other that long,) or Martha the first time Jack "dies" in front of her despite the fact that it was the first time she'd seen him, or Rose the first time Jack "dies" in front of her, or Amy and the Doctor the first time Rory "dies" in front of them, or Amy and the Doctor the second time Rory "dies" in front of them- You get the point. Yang is supposed to be Ruby's sister, but her reactions go between limited and not nearly emotional enough to near non-existent, and we're supposed to buy it as the single most caring and loving older sister that raised Ruby on her own and just loves her oh so much? I don't buy it.

Especially because Yang then completely ignores all the suffering Ruby's been through and how Ruby explicitly said she didn't want to be treated like a perfect girl with all the answers and didn't want to be the leader anymore, and was like "oh yeah Ruby is our perfect leader who never doubts herself and never shows weakness and has never been confused a day in her life." How am I supposed to think of Yang as a caring older sister when she completely ignores Ruby and disregards what she says and what she needs, in order to over-rely on her? Volume 9 made Yang look like a terrible sister tbh.

I will clarify: The problem isn't 'Yang gives Blake attention,' it's that the writers can't seem to write both 'Yang gives Blake attention, cares about her, and loves her as a romantic partner' and 'Yang gives Ruby attention, cares about her, and loves her as a sister.' They tend to push Ruby and Yang's relationship to the back and focus on Blake and Yang's relationship when they could and should be focusing on both sets of dynamics. Because of how much Ruby's relationship with Yang is shoved to the side and Blake and Yang's is emphasized, it does make it feel like Yang cares much more about Blake than she does about Ruby - coupled with things like Yang protectively stepping in front of Blake when Ruby is upset or even earlier, her pulling Blake out of the house with apathy in V6 while Ruby was still in the building and Qrow was passed out drunk on the counter. But the problem isn't 'Yang is written to care about Blake' it's that it feels like the writers only write her to care about Blake and don't care about her other dynamics, which makes it feel like she doesn't really care about Ruby that much at all.

It's very sad, because one of the reasons I originally loved Yang was that I connected with her as an older sister. I love my younger sister very much, I would do anything for her, I want to protect her, but I also think of her as very strong and able to protect herself, similar to how Yang acted in the first five seasons. Yang was one of my absolute favorite characters in RWBY - if not my number one favorite - partially because of how good it felt to see a sibling relationship where they loved and cared about each other and prioritized each other. Now I'm really struggling to like Yang's character at all, and a big reason for that is that it no longer feels like she really cares that much about Ruby. So yeah. XD

TL;DR: I actually completely agree with the people saying Yang is being a bad sister, and her ignoring Ruby is totally a flaw that I'd call out.

Avatar
Avatar

Watching the Spider-verse crunch discussion going on in relation to RWBY and the whole #GreenlightVolume10 thing has been interesting to say the least.

Of course, there's many fucked up people who don't care about the crunch, and even endorse it since ATSV did so well; but from what I've seen, most people have been sympathetic and acknowleged that waiting for the third movie to be finished in due time and treating the workers well is far better than rushing the conclusion to what could be one of the greatest animated film trilogies of the decade.

You make your best work when you don't have the gut-curling dread of unemployment and impossible deadlines hanging like a sword over your head. ASTV could have been even more amazing without the crunch.

Good God, if only we had voices this loud in the RWBY fandom. If only the RWBY fandom's loudest voices were the ones who advocate for ethical treatment above everything else, and not the ones pushing to get more RWBY content made above everything else, fighting tooth and nail and lining the parasitic company's pockets to see their beloved franchise continue, regardless of who would be ground to dust to make it happen.

You are using an unsupported browser and things might not work as intended. Please make sure you're using the latest version of Chrome, Firefox, Safari, or Edge.
mouthporn.net