Scarborough Fair: 5/?
I apologize for the long wait for this chapter. I said I would update every two weeks, and then I dropped the ball on that. I won’t bore you with the details, but life just got crazy. Anyways, I think I have a game plan now that I should be able to update every two weeks, alternating updates with No Wives, No Lovers, No Mothers.
This chapter is about Emma’s recovery, and it’s honestly a gut-wrencher. However, some important plot points also come up, so I can’t really give you places to skip like the last chapter. Hopefully, if you’ve stuck with me this far, you’ll keep reading! I can’t say the angst will cease after this chapter, but the rape will no longer be the main focus. So it gets better in some ways? I guess?
This is also now part of the CS Angsty August, so be sure to check out the other fan fic and fanart from that event!
Summary: Seventeen-year-old Emma Swan has had a charmed life, despite being a foster child. She has a wonderful family who loves her, and the best friends in the world. The only thing that mars her idyllic existence is her birth mother: a homeless woman who mutters nonsensical rhymes and claims to be Snow White. One fateful night, however, Emma’s world is shattered. Perhaps her mother’s rhymes aren’t nonsense after all.
Rated: M for date rape, dubious consent, teen pregnancy, and sexy times (the good kind!)
Words: Over 3k in this chapter
Also on Ao3
Tagging: (let me know if you wish to be removed or added): @snowbellewells @teamhook @kmomof4 @jrob64 @xhookswenchx @thisonesatellite @welllpthisishappening @spartanguard @ohmakemeahercules @tiganasummertree @sparlecorn93 @sals86 @pirateprincessofpizza @xarandomdreamx @zaharadessert @huntressandlioness1 @jamif @undercaffinatednightmare @onceratheart18 @sparlecorn93 @sals86 @pirateprincessofpizza @xarandomdreamx @zaharadessert @huntressandlioness1
Chapter Five
The rest of that night and the next day passed for Emma in a hazy fog punctuated by bouts of crying in her bed curled up in the fetal position. Other times she just lay there staring at the ceiling, trying to let herself be swallowed up by a dark, dark hole that had taken up residence in her chest. She wanted to go numb, to never feel anything ever again. Just when she thought she’d succeeded in emptying herself of all emotion, waves of tears would begin to pound her once again.
She hadn’t had to spell anything out for Killian. He’d simply nodded when she asked for him to take her home, and in the car, he said nothing. The silence was laden with grief, yet she knew she couldn’t have handled any questions, or even worse, platitudes.
Even when they walked through the kitchen door, no words had been necessary. Ingrid had taken one look at Emma, and a single sob had escaped her lips. Emma fell into her embrace, tears finally coming. She heard Liam make a guttural sound followed by a thud. He’d punched something, even had bruises on his knuckles the next day to prove it. Like Killian, however, he said nothing, asked no questions, and refrained from touching her. She could tell the brothers wanted to, the way their hands kept fisting then opening again, the way their arms kept reaching just short of touching her, then falling back to their sides. Emma ached with both relief and sadness at their hesitancy.
@searchingwardrobes Sheesh Melanie, just go ahead and break me heart why don’t you?!? 💔 No, I’m giving you a hard time, but in all seriousness, you have such a way of writing even devastatingly emotional things in a way that I am willing and even glad to read it because it’s what the characters have to go through to get to their happy endings at last. I’m more than willing to feel their hurt with them in exchange for getting to go on the journey you take us on.
Emma’s mourning for her lost innocence, and the rest of the family’s concern and uncertainty of how to help her were so real and raw, you couldn’t help hurting along with them, but wow was it well done. And it also shows how much she is loved and cared for that they try all they can to be there for her - even if it’s just in giving her space and time. Killian’s thoughts in this time sun it up perfectly though: “It wasn’t a lack of patience, at least not for him. He realized that Emma would never be the same person she’d been before, and he wasn’t expecting or asking that of her. He just wanted to see joy in her eyes again. He wanted to see her cheeks pink as she laughed, he wanted to see her collapse against Liam on the couch as he read a book, he wanted her to sit here with him chatting about everything and nothing. In short, he wanted her to live again. Fully. Not for him, but for her own happiness.”
There are also two or three lovely subtle and effective nods to canon here that I have to mention. I thought Neal’s being the child of the single mom Lacey Cassidy was a really clever and sad choice in its own way. And the part about the law and the town not knowing the whole story and Neal being elevated to almost saint-like status by his unfortunate death was very reminiscent of what the show did after Neal died - sometimes to the point of utter frustration when it masked all that he put Emma through. This was an interesting way to spin that into your story and it really hit home. (Even the way Emma reveals to Killian that he didn’t seem like himself, and from what I’ve read of the Impossible book, what was truly going on, plays into the complex father-son dynamic Neal had with Rumple/Gold) Seriously, you could not have picked a much better book to adapt into an OuaT/CS au!!! Most of all though, I love how Killian’s desire to help Emma heal and see her happy and fully living her life again, capture something beautiful about his canon character that can’t be celebrated enough. Yes, he is in love with her, but he also simply and purely wants the best for her, and for her not to close herself off from joy and love and life as she has been for so long when they first meet. This story’s Killian is wishing for that for this Emma too.💖
And then the end of this one, where she asks why he won’t hold her, and his pained, “Oh Emma….” before he runs around to her side of the car to just wrap her up and hold her while she cries. Good heavens!!! It hurt and it was glorious and just WOW breathtaking.🥺😭😍
Ok, I was wrong, @snowbellewells - THIS was the best reblog ever!