If Robert HAD gone through with sleeping with Mike, how would Aaron have won him back?
Oh Wow.
This is an excellent question.
Well, first. I think we need to consider Robert’s point of view during that reunion. He was out there, in a gay club no less, trying to make himself get over Aaron. He was trying to convince himself that he could meet other men and that maybe one of them could spark the same kind of feelings, or at the very least, some feelings that would indicate that maybe it was possible to find love and happiness outside of a grumpy mechanic-turned-scrapyard-owner.
When he went back to Mike, it was because he told himself it couldn’t hurt to try. He’d told Aaron he’d get over him, and he’d been trying to do that. But then Valentine’s Day happened and Robert maybe realised that he’d been keeping this sliver of a door open in terms of his getting back together with Aaron. He hadn’t known that he’d been holding out hope, but then he realised that damn, he had after all. Only that’s not possible anymore. Because as far as he knew, Aaron was at home, with Alex, all happy and loved up. He’d imagined everything between them on Valentine’s Day, and worse yet, he’d possibly made Aaron cheat on his boyfriend.