mouthporn.net
#thoughts and prayers – @religion-is-a-mental-illness on Tumblr

Religion is a Mental Illness

@religion-is-a-mental-illness / religion-is-a-mental-illness.tumblr.com

Tribeless. Problematic. Triggering. Faith is a cognitive sickness.
Avatar
Send them if you like but hopes and prayers do little to help those in a crisis.
Because best wishes and kind words don’t feed families after a flood. They don’t save homes from forest fires or shelter refugees fleeing conflict.
These problems need action, money, aid, shelter, food, water and medicine.
What use are prayers and good intentions here?
I wonder if we see this same passive in-activism for men and boys, with the numerous issues they experience being addressed through feel good platitudes such as ‘men can cry!’
The sentiment is good, but it doesn’t mean much to the homeless men starving on the street, the male survivors barred from refuges, or the fathers losing children in family court.
So, can we do better?
Is ‘men can cry’ the new ‘sending thoughts and prayers?’

--

Sources:

==

Platitudes like "thoughts and prayers" and "men can cry" are cheap and easy words. They're not intended to solve anything or do anything except give the one reciting them a sense of being a good person while keeping a safe distance from the problem. And especially, it's a way of telling men that they've just been doing things wrong, rather than that there are tangible societal disadvantages that require changes in law, policy or resources.

Avatar
“People that post ‘My thoughts and prayers,’ do you know what that's worth? Less than nothing... you aren't giving any of your time, money or even compassion.
Those people are like a wedding photographer who only takes selfies.”
-- Anthony Jeselnik
Source: facebook.com
Avatar

When a disaster strikes and people are all "sending thoughts and prayers", my dad often responds with "yeah well I gave blood what did you do?" and I think about that a lot.

Avatar

Good on him. Literally anything is more useful than “thoughts and prayers.”

For that matter, there isn’t even any evidence they’re actually having thoughts or saying prayers - doing anything but type “thoughts and prayers.” 

It’s the modern equivalent of “Que Sera, Sera.” So easy, so cheap. Some of them probably even have a macro to autofill it. On Facebook they don’t even have to pray any more, just click Like.

Even Xtian scripture says “thoughts and prayers” is useless. In James 2:18-26, Jesus rants at length about “faith without deeds” being useless (dead).

Of course, this is something of a Stone Soup situation, manipulating believers into doing the deeds they could have done without any faith at all, but taking credit for it due to the power of “faith.”

If you can’t actually help in a situation, feel helpless, feel sympathetic, feel bad that you can’t help, and resolve that when you can help, you will help. Instead of wiping away those thoroughly inconvenient feelings of human empathy by pretending you did help.

You are using an unsupported browser and things might not work as intended. Please make sure you're using the latest version of Chrome, Firefox, Safari, or Edge.
mouthporn.net