any theories on earth the forth trove object could be - I think it was bones ?
Hmmmm interesting question! I pulled out some relevant quotes:
At the time, some claimed there were four, or that the fourth had been Unmade, but today’s legends only tell of three (225)
A fourth object lay on the altar, veiled in shadow. But she couldn’t make out more than a gleam of age-worn bone- (548)
And the final one:
Nesta’s stomach churned, but she refrained from mentioning how graphic that vision had been. “There was a fourth object in the vision, but it was in shadow - was there ever a fourth part of that Trove? All I could make out was a bit of ancient bone.”
Rhys ran a hand through his dark hair. “As far as history has confirmed, there are only three objects in the Trove.”
Feyre asked, “What if it’s protected by a spell, like the one to shield all the Trove, to keep people from ever knowing about the fourth object?”
Rhys’s eye shadowed. “Then the Mother spare us, because even Amren only vaguely remembers a rumor of it.” (556)
Because it’s bone the first thing I thought of was a relic, like from a saint. However, I have no idea if that is even a thing in that world. Except... if Amren knew about it, considering what she used to be.... that could be a possibility? But relics don’t do much on their own except act as objects of worship. Maybe it being in Prythian would mean something different?
Or it could be something that was used to keep someone alive à la Jurian? We already have Koschei as a villain but perhaps... he’s an old god, right? Maybe there is someone from his past and he was using Briallyn to help him retrieve that person. The mortal queens strike me as power hungry and not really thinking about the big picture, beyond what they can gain now (or at least, the ones who are still living are like that), so they would be easily manipulated into going for the Trove if they were promised power, unknowingly leading Koschei to something he wants even more.
But then again, being made of bone doesn’t necessarily mean that it’s still in some skeletal structure - it could be an object made of bone that serves an entirely different purpose. I just can’t help thinking that the material itself is important - not gold, not steel, not rock, etc.
And if it’s that old, perhaps it’s linked to the story sjm said would take place far in the past? Or perhaps she decided to take that story and make it relevant to the current timeline with Nesta & Co., and so it would be a blend of the two. An event in the past that has serious implications for Prythian now.
@rayonfrozenwings throw in your 2 cents cuz I know you have thoughts
I love you for this @bookofmirth. I was looking into this myself but on a larger level and not looking closer.
I agree that it can be like a relic or something from a saint in the past. The reason I agree is because I believe that the fourth trove item is in fact the Ivory Horn (Luna’s Horn) from Crescent City: HOEAB.
So in CC we have mention of the Autumn King. One Fae King.
I don’t know whether CC is before/ after/ same time or parallel universe or what it is. I don’t have the information to make that connection as cleanly as I would like just yet and I’ve been looking at these theories since Empire of Storms.
The Autumn King in CC is in possession of a golden crown and he has been looking for the Horn because it is of importance. The horn is made of:
“cracked ivory” (CC)
and is described as being one of three artifacts of Luna. Once it belonged to the first starborn prince Pelias.
“Luna’s Horn was a weapon wielded by Pelias, the first Starborn Prince, during the First Wars. The Fae forged it in their homeworld, named it for the goddess in their new one, and used it to battle the demon hordes once they made the crossing. Pelias wielded the Horn until he died.” (cc:hoeab)
I am not going to write a full theory but rather just answer the question above. I think the Horn is the Fourth Artifact in the Death Trove. It's made of Ivory and that's synonymous for bone - it had enough power to fight demon hordes before it was damaged.
It came from another world, the Harp is an artifact that allows a crossing between worlds as mentioned in ACOSF so it doesn't seem unreasonable that either in the past or the future the Horn would be lost across dimensions/worlds. there is also another quote in CC that describes this crossing.
“This is just a three-page account of Prince Pelias and his bride, Lady Helena. But I didn’t realize that Pelias was actually the high general for a Fae Queen named Theia when they entered this world during the Crossing—and Helena was her daughter. From what it sounds like, Queen Theia was also Starborn, and her daughter possessed the same power. Theia had a younger daughter with the same gift, but only Lady Helena gets mentioned.” Ruhn cleared his throat and read, “Night-haired Helena, from whose golden skin poured starlight and shadows. It seems like Pelias was one of several Fae back then with the Starborn power.” (CC)
I am going to leave this here for now.... because I need to research more. But i’m happy that the Horn is the 4th object hidden in shadow in ACOSF - whether it is shadowed in ACOSF because it is in the ACOTAR world or gone due to destruction (the history we are given of the horn in cc) or moving across worlds is yet to be seen.