I was so excited when, after posting about the first copy of this fic I bound, I was contacted by one of the authors about getting their own copy.
We went with the black bookcloth because this was a known quantity for me. It made it so I was able to add the title and author names to the front cover!
I do this sort of lettering with paper, which may seem counter intuitive to some, especially those that use vinyl. But I use a thin paper that means there isn't much of an edge around the letters, and it's glued using book binding pva, so it's strong, flexible, and designed to bond well to traditional bookcloth. That means it has no acidic adhesive, like some vinyls, and won't yellow or crack or damage the bookcloth and cover in 10 or 15 years.
The downfall is that it can be a little more delicate than vinyl, and I can't add it to this type of spine. You can see in the video the spine is very flexible, and the paper itself would wear out with repetitive opening and closing. But a dust jacket would easily fix this, and I think the author has plans to eventually get one.
I personally think this second copy turned out even better as I had more knowledge under my belt. Very pleased and so honored to have been given some beautiful comments once it was received.