i dont like tweeting longform thoughts about caitlyn for obvious reasons so i’m bringing my thoughts here. and so here’s some thoughts on caitlyn, her ideas on murder, and stuff set up by season 1 of arcane
a lot of what vi says to caitlyn (and later to jayce) rings true — people in the undercity die all the time, die as a direct result of piltover’s hands it’s just that piltover goes about it in a way that doesn’t allow them to think about it. policy, starvation, toxic runoff. indirect means of suffering to take a life. when caitlyn releases the gray onto the streets of zaun, she doesn’t rationalize it as chemical warfare — she rationalizes it as another means to the end of capturing and killing jinx.
she hasn’t been confronted with what the deployment of the gray really means, because nobody tells her what she’s doing is reckless endangerment. most of the remaining council would probably opt to do much worse than caitlyn does! she’s had no time to grieve and process what’s been done to her and her family, and every person in her life who should tell her no won’t — because they don’t have the power to do so (vi) or because the system is built to reward caitlyn’s violent revenge fantasies.
it’s pretty well-established in season 1 of arcane that caitlyn doesn’t kill. ultimately, she wants to protect, and she’s proven she can do that in the case of sevika and vi’s first fight, where she shoots sevika’s arm three times. vi points out that she could’ve killed sevika, should’ve killed sevika, and caitlyn just rolls past that because caitlyn’s previous brushes with death have been pretty impersonal. i believe pretty earnestly that caitlyn could’ve killed jinx, would’ve killed jinx if given the chance to…
but she’s not ready at all to deal with what the reality of taking a life truly means. it’s like when jayce and vi take on silco’s shimmer production and jayce ends up killing a child. it’s easy to rationalize every other person murdered as a dangerous criminal — but what do you do when the people you harm never asked for any of this?
anyways caitlyn really needs a reality check. i’ve been seeing sentiments from other fans who want caitlyn to kill ambessa but i kinda think it’d be a lame way to take the show for various reasons — but most importantly because i really don’t think that’s where caitlyn’s arc is headed. i imagine once the direct result of her command is shown on screen, bloody and beaten, that’s when caitlyn will realize that she’s truly become the monster she so despises.