A Plea to Tolkien Fiction Archive Owners

https://dawnfelagund.tumblr.com/post/171312723953/list-of-tolkien-archives-updated/

Saving Tolkien fan fiction archives is very important to me. I ask anyone who owns a Tolkien archive and is considering closing it to first contact me at queenmabtron at gmail dot com. Shadowfax8, owner of the now defunct West of the Moon (http://west-of-the-moon.net/) hobbit fiction archive, gave me a copy of her database and permission to oversee its move to Archive of Our Own. I am in the middle of rebuying the domain from spammers. I have purchased the domain, database and stories of the now defunct LOTR Fan Fiction (http://lotrfanfiction.com/) from owner Keith Mander and have contacted the Organization for Transformative Works informing them that I wish to donate them to their organization. Rugbytackling (http://rugbytackling.net/), the internet’s greatest Araboro and Vigbean site, has been reborn thanks to the kindness of @afraschatz, who transferred ownership to me. It will stay up for the foreseeable future. I will take responsibility for your sites in the same way or even just offer financial help while you maintain ownership. My preference is to keep the sites online though I was too late with West of the Moon and LOTR Fan Fiction.

Tolkien fandom, please spread the word!

A New History of Fandom Purges

On November 24th, 2018, I posted a list of major deletions of sites or of content on sites that stripped fandom of its history. A bunch of pro-shipper blogs had just been deleted, and people were nervous. I suppose I was thinking “All this has happened before…”

On December 3rd, 2018, Tumblr’s Department of Irony announced the NSFW ban. Thanks for providing this salutary lesson to The Youth and a billion reblogs to me, I guess.

Today, we have AO3 for writing. Audio, images, and video are in as much danger as ever, yet fans attack AO3 every donation drive. For those of you who forget our past…

HERE IS WHAT HISTORY HAS TAUGHT US!

This is only a small taste of the many times that:

It’s not always malicious. It’s not always about us. But we lose every time.

Some of these purges hit everyone. Many of them hit m/m content specifically or female gaze-y material in general. This is why antis are dead wrong. This is why anti-fujoshi policies end up being anti-m/m policies. This is why we need clear labeling, not content restrictions.

This is why we need AO3.

And it’s why we need a solution for audio, visuals, and video too.

So grateful for the historical memory and the long view on a phenomenon many of us have come to late, and/or take for granted.

And this is why AO3 generates twice its goal amount in just a few days: they are irreplaceable.

I’m gonna assume that all the other sites before AO3 allowed slavery fics and pedo shit and Nazi fics and racist ass fics and shit as well and never fixed it, like AO3. They need to fix that shit and ban it if they wanna be great. Asking for donations and not taking a stance to fix that shit don’t sit well with me.

This is a strong argument for multiple archives.

AO3 itself was set up to be a safe haven for even the most repulsive fic. (And, yes, we very much thought in those terms. A test case I brought up while we were writing the TOS was that rpf snuff porn by male authors about female celebrities. Ughhh.)

Protecting vile fanfic is central to what AO3 is. It would have to abandon its mission to be the archive you want.

I personally support this stance on content because the more restrictive archives of the past (which is most of them) did not effectively keep out anything I hate, but they did regularly go after content I want to protect. Even very reasonable “no gross stuff” policies get twisted back on the most vulnerable people and the most #ownvoices content.

But that’s no reason for AO3 to be the only archive or the only valid content policy.

Many archives of the past had mods vetting all fic, whether for content or quality. Many archives took moral stances on underage fic. I can’t think of a single instance of one explicitly trying to be a safe space for fans of color though, unfortunately.

The archive you want is valid, but it’s not AO3.

olderthannetfic: here’s a huge list of the history of fandom purges that have happened and are continuing to happen. purges almost always harm minorities first. AO3 was set up so that it could be a place where no purge ever occurred again.

lady-knuckles: AO3 needs a good purging.

We: y'all remember Fahrenheit 451?

They: omg yes what an inspiration

^^^ this has literally been said in actual [slightly less obvious and slightly more gaslighty] words by actual antis, if anyone thought that was sarcastic.

For real. We’re in the dark timeline.

Is it me or are they focusing on female fanfiction?

The people getting things deleted or me and the commenters?

In general, yes, women’s art is attacked more frequently. You see that in all types of art, high and low, fic and original. I’m sure some of the people advocating censorship are especially upset by fic because they expect women to produce didactic, clean art.

But as for why there’s an overall focus on women, it’s because fic is mostly written by women.

There are some male-heavy spaces like Spacebattles or FIMFiction, but they are the exception, and they don’t change the overall trend in fic fandom. The most relevant data we have on fic writers is probably the following:

FFN Research’s 2010 survey of new user accounts on Fanfiction.net shows:

Centrumlumina’s AO3 Census shows:

Reddit’s r/Fanfiction’s latest survey shows:

Bear in mind that Reddit is famously guy-centric, and their fic space is still way more than half women. The AO3 numbers are probably more representative of fic fandom on Tumblr.

So, yes, there tends to be a female focus in discussions like this on Tumblr.