It’s bad writing.
If Matt or Frank actually listened to Karen’s experiences and respected her, then the story would have gone in a direction the creative teams/executives/whomever did not want.
Acknowledge Karent’s trauma and significance as her own person???
What??? NO.ooOooo…..
No. If they acknowledge that, then who will they falsely idolize as “innocent” and “safe” in order for them to relentlessly dump their shit on while simultaneously demeaning her own experiences because how could she possibly relate? But she has to be their captive audience for all their drama. Sadly, for all the glimpses that might give us hope of otherwise, in the recent seasons Karen is a balm when she is around Matt or Frank, not her own character. It’s been such a regression, especially in TPS2.
For all the strength and depth Karen Page has as a character, the writers and creative teams still really love to have men around her, men she respects and cares for, treat her with such coddling disrespect because… well, it’s the man’s story, ultimately, not hers, and that’s what serves their actions and arcs better.
I guess.
I mean, I wouldn’t write it like that. But whatever. I’m especially baffled by Frank’s response to Karen this season. It’s such a rug-pull from the writers. And just. Bad. Annoyingly bad. What’s the trope? The “Idiot Ball?” But the writers are holding the Idiot Ball. And Karen Page just shuts her mouth and deals with it probably because they justify it as ‘she wouldn’t want to burden the men with her truth’ but that’s BS. It is. It is such reductive BS. It just gives them the excuse to keep having dudes shovel guilt and belittlement on her and without her being able to shut down their bullshit like any sane person would. Because then the men would have to challenge their own bullshit reasoning and the plot would have to change accordingly. But that’s not what the writers and creative teams want - they want their edgy male leads to be edgy. Karen would take that away and so it can’t happen.
I’m so tired of these shows. In this regards, both the seasons have really, really let me down. Some of the reasoning used for the narrative direction… I just cannot comprehend. Why? WHy. Why…..