- richard ii, william shakespeare
can we just talk real quick about how when Ed was telling Izzy "Ooh, now there's an idea, I haven't done that (died) yet." he pulls out his fucking knife
which he then is holding out-of-shot as he says "Haven't died yet, have I? Maybe we should try that."
what’s a little murder-suicide between husband and wife?
izzy's face is so frozen in this whole scene and it's hilarious to me because like. i know that someone on twitter was making this comparison earlier, that ed/izzy are just like hook/smee
but izzy doesn't even look surprised. ed has absolutely casually brought up suicide before, and izzy has had to learn to Not React
and i'm just thinking of when they're super married in Hook (1991) and hook is gonna shoot himself in the head while ordering smee not to stop him, until smee stops him, and then hook blames smee for not intervening soon enough and smee kisses him and tells him it's gonna be alright:
if ed/izzy were even remotely as healthy as the hook/smee marriage they'd be FINE
This scene gets 10x sadder when you realize that's the reaction Ed was trying to get. He wanted Izzy to wrestle the knife from his hand and tell him it was gonna be alright. He wants to be comforted but doesn't realize that Izzy's broken in exactly the kind of way that prevents him from understanding this. So Izzy just sees an "erratic", "half-insane" man who he thinks says all this stuff to get on his last nerves; and Ed just keeps pushing Izzy's buttons, slowly chipping away at whatever's left of the two of them, desperately trying to be seen :(
protagonist bias is a funny thing bc if you look at what izzy and stede's first few interactions are like from izzy's perspective it's like:
- you bought some nice british hostages with your own money from a tribe as a way of supporting local businesses. when out of nowhere some stupid british aristocrat jumped out of the bush, broke your friend's nose, and stole one of the hostages that you paid for
- moving on from this, your boss doesn't say much other than mock you for being bested at swordplay (even though it was an ambush and completely unprofessional) before telling you to go invite the little asshole onto the ship. presumably it's to kill him (the uszh) for fucking up his business, but honestly you just wanna wash your hands of the whole thing and move on
- your boss, god rest his half insane soul, insists though and that you specifically need to go when you'd rather just send one of the boys. so you go out to a bar that you fucking hate and find the obnoxious man from before to let him know that your boss wants a word
- everybody knows who your boss is. he's fucking blackbeard for fuck's sake! except for stede fucking bonnet apparently who immediately responds to your polite invitation by accusing you of stealing his hostages (which you paid for!) and calls you iggy
- so fuck this guy, right? blackbeard's gonna kill him anyways, and if he wants to make it worst on himself by not having the manners to even listen for two seconds to explain who your boss is, then that's on him!
- "so i'll tell my boss you're declining then"
- "tell him he has terrible tastes in flunkies and that he can suck eggs in hell!"
- well fine then! you will!
- once again, you just want to be done with the whole thing, and maybe you omit a few facts as you relay the news to your boss. did stede know that your boss is blackbeard? well, it seems like stede fucking bonnet knows everything in this entire fucking world so yeah you suppose he did
- you don't understand your boss's orders most of the time, but in the end you still follow them so when he says attack the spanish you attack the spanish. he must have it in real bad for this guy if he wants to kill him personally, and honestly it doesn't seem worth the effort to you, but who the fuck are you to complain?
- and when things are all done and set, you're ready for this whole ordeal to be over. you know the steps from here. repair the ship, kill the crew, move the fuck on until your boss gets some other insane idea in his head and makes you track down another random bloke for the fun of it
- but no... you're going through the motions, but your boss is fucking around and playing with toy ships and screaming about being bored and wanting to try dying. you wait for as long as you can, coaxing him into thinking of a plan and moving on, but it seems he's finally snapped and is really set on you all dying
- also he's playing dress up. for some fucking reason he's playing dress up while you're only hours out from certain death because it's too late to run now. even as you try to explain the seriousness of the situation your boss continues to brush you off because he's definitely truly actually crazy now! this is it! the man has snapped and think he's an aristocrat running around in tights and waiting to die!
- and maybe you're a bit rough when you ask stede how the ship is stocked, but now isn't the time for niceness. unfortunately, the man's a fucking idiot and has no idea about any of the basics of running a ship because he's the worst pirate captain you've ever met (and that's including calico jack for fuck's sake) you are surrounded by incompetency and it's all stede fucking bonnet's fault because the man couldn't honor a fucking business transaction
- and then things are fine. because yes, your boss is crazy, but no, not that crazy (yet.) you're embarrassed for snapping and slink off to resign like you said. you even apologize for the harshness of your words, but you get that you acted out of line
- but you don't go. because your boss asks you to stay. the only reason why you don't go is because your boss asked you to stay. because he's depressed and he's tired and he can't keep doing this pirate shit anymore and you know that. so when he says he has a plan to 1. leave piracy and become a wealthy aristocrat 2. make you captain once he's gone and 3. kill that fucking twat. yeah, you're all in baby
- and you know what your boss does instead?
- he fucks stede bonnet right on deck out in the open because stede bonnet is a menacing, seductive, slut
he called him daddy and also cried
Edward Did A Ton Of Things Wrong And We Shouldn’t Pretend Otherwise. Not Even As A Joke.
I know it’s fun to joke about Edward Teach doing nothing wrong, but I think it’s been taken far too far. His wrongs are serious and major and deserve closer examination.
- He fell for a rich landed gentleman, and only the rich landed gentleman, when Frenchie was right there. Frenchie was displaying bravery and insightfulness while stupid fucking Stede Bonnet was laid up in a fever dream, moaning some other person’s name.
- Ed didn’t fall on Frenchie and start kissing him when Frenchie immediately picked up on the fact that the French versions of Stede Bonnet had hurt him.
- He’s more enamored of Stede’s incitement of chaos and distress on the French boat than he has any right to be with Frenchie right there. What did Stede do? A little reverse psychology that played on their inadequacies to get the French gentry to play the game. That’s it. All the real work was done because Frenchie knew where to go for the dirt, and thanks to connections Frenchie formed. While it was cool that Stede knew how to get them to play themselves by agreeing to the game, it wasn’t a necessary step as the information could’ve been relayed other ways. Plus, Frenchie pointed out to Stede they weren’t all that fancy, so he probably would’ve known how to get them to set themselves up to, and could’ve give Ed the satisfaction of being the one to entice them into the game and deliver the info.
- He continues to be interested in Stede and only Stede, while Frenchie is right fucking there! Had he taken the time to get to know Frenchie, he might’ve realized Frenchie could teach him much of what Stede could, but with more nuance and detail.
In conclusion, Edward did everything wrong where it matters. We shouldn’t gloss over his mistakes and moments of bad judgement. They’re a part of what makes him the person he is. It’s uncomfortable to think about, and I have a hard time coming to grips with it myself, but that doesn’t mean I’m gonna just hide from reality and pretend the man has no major shortcomings.
He could be sleeping with Izzy and Frenchie, while Spanish Jackie watches and gives directions and tips and joins in if it so pleases her (and if they’re so lucky), right now. Instead, he’s off somewhere nursing the pain left by a man who says “hi all”. If that ain’t a wrong, then right don’t exist.
In light of recent developments…
… bringing this back to say that I dare to hope it isn’t too late for Ed to change his wicked ways by embracing Frenchie and/or Ouizzy.
All is not lost Edward Teach! You can still save yourself and change your wicked ways by doing some downright wicked things to, with, and around Frenchie. And in doing such wickedness, you will make @bromelads happy, which is the greatest righteousness you can aspire to.
Thank you for bringing the truth to the forefront <3 Let it not be said that we don't love Edward as he is or believe in second chances. The Ed apologia ends here u_u Edward Teach do better*
*Frenchie I hope that's clear ;)
Ok, maybe Izzy is a *little bit* demonic.
(I have one Izzy joke and unfortunately it REALLY scratches my brain, so you’ll be seeing creature Izzy every few weeks until I grow bored or GO 2 comes out, whichever comes first (my money is on GO))
…Spewer
[insert some smart remark]
transmasc blackbeard: izzy. i’ll take T in my room
✨Happy Oluwednesday dear gays ✨
how to talk to short people (colorized)
hey remember how mary tried to kill stede while he was asleep to sever their relationship permanently? and also remember how ed physically mutilated izzy while he was asleep, and then used that as a pointed reinforcement of their commitment to each other? Yeah.
remember how izzy/ed and mary/stede exist as mirrored pictures of stifling broken down relationships, one that is kept alive forcibly, dragged along half-conscious mutilated and mangled as it is, and one which is mercifully put down, left to rest now in peace.
tallahassee (2002) is an album by the mountain goats detailing the last resort efforts of the alpha couple to save their crumbling marriage even though both partners know how bad they are to each other. tired of themselves and one another they begin drinking themselves to death while their house rots and crumbles around them. fixating on the smallest moments of genuine love and happiness they delude themselves into thinking that there is anything worth salvaging left anymore. sick of dragging their marriage & themselves towards a slow painful death, the album culminates in the couple burning their house down, possibly also dying in the process,
he called him daddy and also cried
Izzy sending Jack to Stede’s ship like “here are the coordinates” and he just gives him this
jack, who can’t read for shit: thanks partner, on it
You telling me some cats steadied these hands?