League getting a singular cohesive universe, Arcane being canon and Why I'm worried
[disclaimer: This is all the personal opinions of one sleep deprived rando on the internet and its fine if you disagree with anything I say]
On a surface level, the decision to make to make Arcane canon and make the runeterra universe one cohesive canon sounds pretty harmless and actually good. After all, Arcane's writing was really good and the idea of having a consistent universe sounds really good in theory.
The problems start to arise when you remember that Marvel and DC have been trying to make a singular cohesive universe for decades and have both failed every single time. It's nearly impossible to make a single cohesive canon when you have so many characters and stories and that's not even getting into the implications of Arcane being canon
Arcane being canon
Now, on paper, it doesn't sound too bad and if I'm being completely honest, I wouldn't have minded if they just implemented some worldbuilding from Arcane (like shimmer) into the main universe, my problem arises with the fact they are planning on making the Arcane characters fully canon
The reason why I personally think Arcane worked so well is because it wasn't confined to the main canon and was able to use it as a jumping off point to do its own thing. By making it canon, they're essentially going to have to do one of three things:
- Let Arcane continue as it's going and just have the Arcane lore and characters become the main universe's lore and characters (essentially nuking the old characters we've had for years out of existence)
- Restricting what Arcane can do and making it so the Arcane characters eventually become their main universe counterparts (which I feel would be a little forced even if they somehow manage to do it semi smoothly with the good writing)
- Instead of one completely taking over the other, they merge the Arcane and main universe characters (That's probably the best option but that still means we're gonna lose something)
They essentially can't do anything without either changing or erasing parts of the main universe's lore or Arcane's lore. There is also a part of me that's scared that if Arcane lore does overtake the main universe lore, it's going to set a precedent for potential future shows doing their own thing with the main lore and then that show's lore overriding the main one
Optimism
Okay so before I move onto the next section, I do want to share a bit of cautious optimism I'm feeling in regards to this. Call this copium if you will but who knows? Maybe Riot will have actually learned something from the Sentinels of Light event and will actually give this whole "one singular canon" thing the money and resources it desperately needs to work. Maybe after seeing Arcane's success, they'll allow creatives more freedom but have weekly meetings across all departments and constant check ups from lore coordinators to make sure nothing contradicts itself. Maybe Riot being a gaming company, and not a comic book publisher with comic issues coming out frequently. will actually allow them to somehow manage to do the impossible and make a cohesive universe. Maybe if there are screw ups, they'll be minor and be patched up relatively quickly
i fucking wish Anyways, moving on
"One Big Shared Canon" and the Restrictions on Creativity
As mentioned before, making sure nothing contradicts itself in a universe with this many characters is almost impossible. I wouldn't mind the whole "one cohesive universe" thing if I didn't know it was almost impossible to manage and that the easiest way to have a strict cohesive universe is to restrict everything and simple it down and that scares me. Riot the corporation literally didn't give two shits about lore until it made a line on a graph go up for them. I'm scared they're not gonna give this the effort and funding necessary to actually maintain this
An pre existing example of them already restricting creativity because of the canonisation of Arcane and Runeterra becoming a singular shared narrative would be Legends of Runeterra. LOR has been carrying most of the main universe's lore and worldbuilding. It has expanded so many forgotten champions and is one of the main reasons Runeterra's lore is so vast, complex and interesting and Riot fucking pulled the plug on it, by cutting its budget and forcing a lot of its artists to move to other departments, and told the remaining LOR team to stop developing all new narrative content because they didn't want any runeterra lore to be developed independently and not as a part of the entertainment division. All of this to say making everything one big shared canon, they will probably end up just restricting most of their creative departments and creating less interesting and unique art and stories as a result which I think is a shame
In conclusion, fuck capitalism (kinda ironic, because, yknow, arcane,,) and go play lor/hj