Tokyo Ghoul and the Violent, Dominant Woman: pt. 2
So, in Part 1 I discussed the Dominant/Sadistic women in Tokyo Ghoul. Now we’ll be moving on to the next group:
I’ve chosen to separate these characters out from the pure sadists of the first meta because, while they may enjoy fighting (and even, sometimes, killing), they are not purely sadistic and do not simply kill for the fun of it.
Similarly to Rize, when Touka is introduced, she is played up as being feminine and somewhat weak. Hide hits on her in Anteiku, and later, when Kaneki sees her, she’s being harassed by an old man who clearly intends to molest her, at least.
Of course, his fun doesn’t last long, because Touka is anything but weak.
Touka’s facade is employed far less than Rize’s. Later in that scene she mentions that she wasn’t even hungry. She didn’t use it to lure this man in as prey…she didn’t even want to eat him. He was just a creepy old bastard who was attacking what he assumed to be a helpless young girl. Since her meals are supplied by Anteiku, she only kills this man because he’s freaking out about Kaneki’s eye. The truth is, Touka is not a sadist, nor does she particularly enjoy the hunt. However, Touka is tough. She’s a lot stronger than Kaneki, and we get plenty of scenes of her beating him and/or saving him in tough situations, such as the fight with Tsukiyama in the church.
It isn’t until Kaneki goes through his torment at Jason’s hand that we really see him as being more powerful than Touka. It is only due to Touka’s strength and willingness to engage in violence that Kaneki makes it as far as he does.
However, Touka’s tough identity is also stripped from her over the course of the story’s events. After her fight with Ayato, she’s very much changed. Though to some extent, the changes in her personality truly begin when she see’s Mado’s wedding band. Even so, we see her becoming much more involved at school, building a friendship with a human, studying to get into Kamii. Ultimately, she’s excluded from the final Anteiku showdown, and goes on to open her own cafe. Though some of her rough edges are still intact in :RE, she’s ultimately presented in the story as being much more feminine and soft than she was in :RE. Even the ways that she’s drawn changes throughout the manga from a harder style to a still androgynous, but softer style to :RE, where she’s very soft-looking.
Beginning of Tokyo Ghoul:
It remains to be seen how much Touka has changed as a character, but her dominance seems to be quite diminished. Again, I’ll allow the reader to come to their own conclusions about this evolution, but I also think it’s important to recognize that Touka’s passivity in :RE is complex; she’s allowing Kaneki more agency in that she’s giving him the opportunity to choose to return to her and the others, to the ghoul world. She no longer comes off as super rough and tough, but it remains to be seen whether her dominant/fighter side is still intact.
One of my favorite female characters in Tokyo Ghoul, and one of the ones I was most excited to write about, is Akira Mado. Though I would firmly categorize Mado as a “fighter,” she’s undoubtedly a dominant woman, to the point of acting in ways that are considered fairly socially unacceptable. For example, she spends a great deal of time in the beginning on testing and challenging Amon, who is not only above her in rank, but is also male and directly in charge of her. With all of her male coworkers, Akira takes no shit; if they are kind to her, she is kind to them. If they are sarcastic and mean to her (lookin’ at you, Seidou), she throws it right back to them, with more sharpness and more wit. Akira is beautiful, incredibly intelligent, hardworking, and somewhat cold. She engages in stereotypically feminine behaviors (such as eating less to watch her figure) and dresses hyper-femininely, even in combat situations, but much of this comes off as a mechanism to assert her gender, despite her decidedly masculine interests and behaviors.
She is clearly very sexually unavailable to the men around her, prompting frustration from Takizawa, who describes her as an “asexual weapons fanatic.” Despite this, she is often portrayed from domineering angles (especially in fights) and uses several quinques that look and behave like whips.
(Why are you in a dress and heels right now, Akira?)
Akira’s image, in other words, recalls that of a certain kind of dominatrix…the kind that remains fully clothed while upstaging and beating men who are quite clearly her inferiors. Not that Akira is reduced to this image, quite the contrary; she’s portrayed as a very complex character, with a depth of emotion and a wealth of talent usually reserved for complex male characters. However, I do not believe that the repeated images of Akira wielding a whip and dispatching male ghouls are an accident…and neither is her ability to outsmart and stand up to the male investigators around her.
Still, while Akira takes pleasure in the fight, she’s hardly a sadist, nor is she unfeeling. Perhaps the reason why Akira is always fully dressed in her moments of domination is due to the fact that she is, in fact, vulnerable. Unlike Eto or Nutcracker, we see moments of intense, almost uncomfortable vulnerability from Akira.
Since she’s a newcomer, it will be interesting to see how things progress with Ihei. However, it is already quite clear that Ihei is another female character who is quite dominant, though she doesn’t appear to be at first blush.
Thought she seems cute, young, and sleepy-eyed, Ihei is a brutal and skilled fighter.
Further, Ihei knows that she’s strong, and an impressive fighter. Additionally, Ihei doesn’t take the same pains to retain a feminine appearance that Akira does; though she has pink, girlish hair, she prefers menswear, and never goes into battle in skirts.
I imagine there will be more to say about Ihei in the future, but I would certainly consider her in the ranks of dominant women in Tokyo Ghoul.
With all of these characters, the erotic/violence dichotomy is more muted than it was for the Sadists, but at the same time, sadism more often than not carries notes of the erotic in almost every form. There are other women who might fit into this category, such as Matsumae and Irimi, however, they are quite mysterious side characters and we don’t know much about them. The similarity between these characters and the Sadists is that, with the exception of :RE-Touka, they are presented as dangerous, dominant, and objectively superior to most of the men around them. Unlike the sadists, however, none of these women have been subjugated and/destroyed by the men around them. Again, I will allow the reader to come to their own conclusions regarding that observation.
Stay tuned for Pt. 3: The Abusers.