One thing I love so much about the merman scene - apart from using real water and not CGI - is that they used a "real"/practical tail and no CGI either.
Because thats my biggest pet peeve with The Little Mermaid 2023, the tails looks horrible, especially of the sisters, but also Ariel looks... meh
Not even the bra is real. You know how amazing the bras could have looked with some good body paint? Like Mystique... *cough* back to the actual topic
Mermaid tails look unreal anyway... because mermaids do not exist. So the biggest challenge is to create a tail that looks a) convincing and b) pretty.
The point is: Animate a dragon, no matter how shitty it looks, its convincing, because a dragon is supposed to look unreal. It doesn't exist. We do not know how a dragon looks. But mermaids...? they have basically fish tails, and we know how fishs look. An this picture above looks nothing like a fish. It just looks unreal. And that ruins the illusion
This is why it is so much better to use a tail costume, inspired by an actual fish. To keep the illsuion real
All the details that went into the tail:
this is how you get such a realistic tail movement:
gif by: @juliewlters
Because it is a real tail in real water. And thats honestly the dedication i expect when you write a mermaid story... and not just horrible CGI
This!!
But it’s so unforgivable for the Little Mermaid movie because the mermaid tail market is so incredibly talented and capable, and has been for decades. The H2O Just Add Water tails? All real, with hand-laid scales and silicone casing. What I’d call basically the perfect tails. With some touching up around the waist? Flawless. But Mertailor (fuck that guy but still, the product), MerBellas, Findolk productions? So many options for gorgeous, high quality silicone tails! Unique and colorful and amazingly realistic. And I can’t even discuss the bras. Those are ATROCIOUS, when making a practical bra would be so easy and beautiful.
I highly agree. Why they didn't made one bra that the actress could put on and off easily and that still looked detail and glittery (see Stedes tail) is beyond me. Honestly. That would have saved so much costs compared to CGI. Oh i forgot, you have to pay someone to do it. Silly me
And the tails?
There are so many amazing onces out there. And this one here is not made with a huge ass Disney budget. And even them already look amazing in water:
Compared to that, the Disney CGI one just looks cheap. And those are made for swimming. So...
And there are so many amazing options for bras:
So high repesct to the whole OFMD crew for choocing a real mermaid tail and not some cheap CGI