CANJY Head canons
So first of all, yes I still love Wolfstar and ship it as much as always, but lately Canjy (Caradoc Dearborn/Benjy Fenwick) have taken over my heart. I’m in a text rp group with some amazing friends and @meektheraccoon and I have fleshed out these boys so much that they own my heart. I’ve published one Canjy fic already, am working on another, and have a massive collab fic Meek and I are working on that I am so excited about. But yes, I’m still working on my Wolfstar fics as well. My time has just been super limited lately so I haven’t been able to write as much as I want to.
Here’s a few of the HC’s @meektheraccoon and I have for our favorite boys, and remember they’re just our versions, ALL versions of these characters are valid and need some love!
- Benjy was a Gryffindor and a star Quidditch player, he was signed to the Falmouth Falcons immediately upon graduation from Hogwarts.
- Benjy got seriously injured in a match and had to quit playing professionally. He has some permanent damage to his spine, but it’s not severe thankfully.
- He’s always been a bit of a bookworm and after his injury works at Flourish and Blott’s, but dreams of owning his own book store one day. A lot of people didn’t take his intelligence and love of reading seriously because he’s a blond pretty boy athlete, but those that know him well know he’s much more himself with his nose in a book, reading glasses perched on his nose, than he is on a broom, even with his considerable talent.
- My boy has a serious issue with rambling and word vomit which is endearing and adorable, but drives him batty. He just can’t help himself sometimes and just spews what’s on his mind. He’s a bit of an awkward mess at times, really.
- The one thing he holds in is his love for his best friend, Caradoc though. He’s been in love with Caradoc for ages and even though they’ve been “fuck buddies” for a long time, Benjy believes Caddy could never think of him as more than a good shag and his best friend.
- My boy is so wrong.
- Caradoc is a mountain of a man, handsome and looks intimidating because of his size, but he’s a softy who works as a baker in his sister’s bakery. He was a Hufflepuff and a few years ahead of Benjy in school and they actually “met” when Benjy came into the bakery to pick up some pastries for his sister.
- Caddy was actually Benjy’s “gay awakening” when he was in Hogwarts and when he sees Caddy at the bakery he makes an excuse to come back almost every day for a week before he gets up the nerve to ask Caddy out.
- They end up becoming best friends, hooking up occasionally, neither of them realizing that the other wants more. Both letting their insecurities and fear of messing up the friendship blind them to the other’s feelings.
- Honestly, they’re just pining oblivious idiots and I’m so here for it.
- Benjy actually dates Remus, who he meets at an Order meeting, for a while pre-Wolfstar, to try and move on from Caddy. It doesn’t work though because obviously his heart belongs to Caddy and Remus is in love with Sirius.
- They part as friends though and have a really close bond for the rest of their lives, much to Sirius’ chagrin.
- Sirius and Benjy can’t stand each other really, it all stems from jealousy when Remus and Benjy were dating and Caddy and Sirius were casually hooking up during that time. They put up with each other though because of their respective partners and Remus and Caddy just roll their eyes at their rivalry and laugh at their antics over firewhiskey.
I could go on and on and on about these babies, but I’ll save more for the fics we’re working on. ;-)
Oh these are absolutely wonderful headcanons! I love that you have them as the same age as the marauders and totally intertwined with their lives.
For me I see them as older, maybe in their 50s or 60s by the time the first war comes around. As I said in my tags, Caradoc is the more fleshed out of the two but here are some of my musings so far! Caradoc is Euphemia Potter’s brother, younger brother, and James’s godfather. He absolutely dotes on him and whenever James needs to get away from his parents, he’s always welcome at Caradoc’s place in Cokeworth where he has his own bedroom. His house is actually not that far from the Evans’ and Lily knew of Caradoc before she ever went to Hogwarts but she always just knew him as a doctor. The Dearborns are originally from Yorkshire, with the family home located located within York itself.
He’s a healer working in St. Mungo’s but also has a small practise that serves Cokeworth County and the surrounding area. He knew he wanted to be a healer from a young age but was not a natural potion maker so out of all his studies he applied himself the most here so that he would be able to get the necessary grades. It paid off and in the end he became quite competent and found a lot of enjoyment in it once he ‘cracked the code’. He’s a very skilled healer and is often drafted in to deal with the more complex cases whether it’s a nasty case of dragon pox, memory charms gone awry, or curses with horrible side effects. He treated Andromeda Black after Bellatrix curses her for her relationship with Ted. The fact she’s been left with chronic pain and fatigue as a result is a sore spot for him and he’s still trying to find someway to help her. (ofc with canon, he is disappeared before ever finding a cure. Sob)
Benjy Fenwick is Irish by way of Brixton. His parents moved to London when he was a kid and the Fenwicks became close friends with the Meadowes family who also live in Brixton. He’s a Slytherin half blood and as i said in my tags, I don’t have much more than that. He and Caradoc were in the same year at school but they didn’t have much of relationship there. Caradoc found him irritating and self absorbed but begrudgingly admitted he was an excellent Keeper and Quidditch captain. They met again once out of school and Caradoc was treating him for ???? something either a bad case of dragon pox or an injury that required more specialist help. At this point they’re maybe in their mid to late 20s and there’s an instant connection that throws them both into the back foot.
I have so much more I want to explore with them. But I think I’ve rambled on enough now lmao
Ahhhh I love these head canons @martelldoran ! I can’t wait to read what you’ve got planned. I love any and all hc’s for these boys, they need all the love and attention.
Ahhhh Canjy!!! I love all of these!
My interpretation is (heavily) influenced by Jen and Meek haha.
They’re both a year older than Sirius and Remus, and both in Gryffindor!
Caradoc is huge and intimidating and has the biggest brain ever. (If you piss him off he’ll beat you up with his fists and then utterly humiliate you with his words!) He’s hugely competitive and super logical - often the only person actually thinking things through, especially compared to the crackheads of the Marauders gang. He immediately befriends the Prewett Twins and Kingsley in first year, the Marauders and co in second and spends most of his time at Hogwarts with Remus thinking up ways to pizzaz up pranks (and devious ways to not get caught!) He makes prefect in fifth year and deliberately abuses his privileges by sneaking in huge amounts of food from the kitchens at night and having swim parties with everyone in the prefect bathroom. So he’s pretty much having a ball until fifth year when Benjy Fenwick drops in from Ilvermony in America.
Benjy moved to England from America. He’s a POC and a halfblood, which lead to a lot of racism from the muggles and discrimination from the wizards. He’s an insanely good quidditch player and decides to move to England in the hopes that he can go pro and send some money back home for his parents and younger sister. The first thing he does in England is buy a whole thing of makeup and he proceeds to sashay into Hogwarts with lipstick and eyeshadow and the works. He’s spent 15 years being closeted in America and what does he have to lose? It’s his only chance to be out and proud and he does so unabashedly. He immediately gets onto the Gryffindor Quididtch team as a Seeker (pissing off Caddy who spends most of his time hitting Bludgers at him) and proceeds to spend most of his first year at Hogwarts teasing Caddy, befriending the Marauders and training like crazy.
They both basically manage to piss each other off until the middle of sixth year, when the annoyance starts turning into pining. It’s pretty much what one would expect - little glances and winks and origami roses. They kiss for the first time in a Muggle bar, on the night that Benjy gets scouted and agrees to go pro.
Once they leave Hogwarts, it’s the best year of both their lives. Benjy gets a lot of bad press for being gay but he’s so incredibly good that there’s not much else to say. Caddy trains to be an Auror, and quickly looks like he’s going to be the youngest in over a century. They spend one beautiful year and then the rumbling starts - Voldemort had grown in power and everything is shattered.
I love to picture a scene in my head where Caradoc pleads for Benjy to go home, back to America, away from all the fighting. Benjy refuses though - “I’ve seen things like this before, people who think they’re better than others simply because of their skin or gender or ability to do magic. How can I let that happen here?”
“You’ll die,” Caradoc had said. “He’ll go for people - for halfbloods first - “
“And what if he wins?” Benjy had shaken his head. “You think he’ll stop in England? What if he reaches America? What if he reaches my family?”
They’re one of the first people to sign up when Dumbledore asks for volunteers, along with Sirius and Remus and James and Lily, all the other people that they had grown up with. They form the best of the Order, people ruthless and cunning and skilled enough to hold off the Death Eaters, paying in blood as the war advanced.
I think that Benjy’s magic is slightly different, being raised in America. I always headcanon him as being great with defensive magic - wards and barriers and wickedly lethal traps. The two of them make a great team - Caradoc’s brain and Benjy’s ingenuity, making it nearly impossible for the Death Eaters to find the Order for almost 2 years. They were good enough that Voldemort knew that if he were to have any chance of finding the Order, they would have to go.
They kill Caradoc first, sets a trap with Muggle-borns as bait. He manages to get them out but dies in the process, Benjy screaming at him to wake up. Benjy manages for almost 3 months after that, holding up the wards and the traps himself. He helps James and Lily shield their house, sets hundreds of deadly traps for the death eaters and tries to remember what life was like with Caddy.
But even he’s not strong enough to manage so many places at once, not with a Spy. When the Death Eaters find the Order Headquaters, Benjy buys everyone enough time to get out, to run. He locks the Death Eaters inside a house and then blows it up, with him inside of it. They never find his body.
They would be the first. Marlene and Dorcas go down barely a month after, the Prewett’s and Mary after them. It’s only after the protections are gone that James and Lily finally agree to do the Fidelius, and ask Peter to be the Keeper.
@ashes-and-ashes I love this so much but it hurts!! Obviously the version of Canjy that Vern and I have been working on is like my primary HC, but omg I love this so much too! I love any and all love that these boys get and every interpretation is so amazing!!