I’ve realized that one of the things that bothers me about Jem and Magnus and now Aline is that none of them have Asian last names, and they’re all half-Asian, which to me just says that Casserole wanted to make their non-white heritage as invisible as possible.
To clarify the half-Asian point: mixed race people are full inheritors of their non-white heritage, and the fact that Cassie doesn’t bother to try is very telling. Mixed Asians are Asian, and should be portrayed as such, but white authors like Cassie treat them as discount-white.
I have a mixed-race SEAsian protag in one of my own WIPs. But the difference is I’m writing him as actually mixed-race, with all the emotional baggage that comes with rediscovering your culture after being raised away from it. Cassie just slaps a half-Asian label on her characters and calls it a day. And not only that, she made sure that all of them have Asian mothers, so that in her fantasy patriarchy, they would have white last names from their fathers.
And sure, it doesn’t need to be the focus of the story, but it’s NOT THAT HARD to drop hints, like mentions of an altar or the lingering smell of incense, or always having a platter of fresh tangerines on the sidetable. Where are the mentions of doubling up on holidays? Of mixed feasts with turkey and potatoes and fried rice and roast pork? I think Cassie has them drink tea a few times, but could you get any more stereotypical?
tl;dr: Mixed-race PoC deserve to be represented with just as much nuance and grace as any other PoC, not used as shields so a white author can claim to have representation without putting in any effort.
Adding a slight correction: there’s one more Asian character, Divya. She’s the only Asian character to have an Asian last name. Which… i really don’t want to get into all the fucking baggage of East Asian women marrying white men in this post.
This is her entire entry in the fandom wiki. What the fuck does she actually look like?
I mean, why would CC put any thoughts into it? Why would CC in her 900 page book of unnecessary sex, and steamy scenes, and horny white teenagers take the time to describe divya a little bit? I mean an Indian woman? Of course she’s going to be quite. Of course she’s going to be the perfect, sweet, inncent girl, shy girl. Why would CC show am Indian girl fighting, kicking some ass, being sassy, sarcastic and intelligent? I mean that’s only reserved for whites isn’t it? Indian woman? Of course the only thing that describes her is her nose stud. And of course brown woman exist only to prop up and support white protagonist.
Fin.
@CC and the fandom
The only other full blooded Asian in CC’s books in Shinyun Jung from The Red Scrolls of Magic, and later she is revealed to be the villain. This really says a lot doesn’t it. There wasn’t even any effort put into her character, the only signs of her Korean heritage are her bringing up which dynasty she used to live in, but other than that she could’ve been white for all i know.
Shinyun,,, is not, as far as I know, a particularly Korean name. Like, maybe very technically? Can someone korean confirm or deny this?
Hi, I’m half Asian.
- Mixed Asians are mixed, meaning we all have different identities, personalities, cultures, heritage. Some of us grew up with both/multiple cultures, some of us with only one. For my case, I am more of the latter as I was born and raised in a European country, and the way I was raised, I wasn’t much in touch with my Asian heritage. But there’s nothing wrong with that! I know who I am and it’s all that matters, I don’t need any labels. Mixed Asians are not just Asians who you can all portray the same way. You can’t paint all of us with the same brush.
- I personally think that Jem’s mixed heritage was very well portrayed in the books, but that’s just my personal opinion.
- I will not comment on that shadowhunters wiki page as it’s fandom content and yes I agree it’s pretty cringy, but... Y’all keep forgetting my girl Lily Chen! She’s also a full blooded Asian.
- Def not Korean sorry, but I’m pretty sure Jung Shinyun is a Korean name. (what even is a ‘not particularly’ Korean name?) Jung is a common Korean family name and you can find notable Koreans named Shin-Yun / Shin-Yeon with some research.