#Bullshit
I love that THIS is the moment you can see exactly when Killian knows that something is not right. Rumplestiltskin himself saying that he will cooperate. The tic in Colin’s jaw is subtle, but it’s this almost as much as the shift of his eyes (which had been consciously looking away from the man he still hates), that tells the viewer that the character knows that Rumple is lying. He may have suspected that Belle had a fake dagger, but the Dark One’s eagerness to “prove” that he’s turned over a new leaf by having his wife USE it to compel him that reveals the truth of Killian’s belief. Rumple NEVER does anything without making a deal; Rumple always finds a way to screw people over, especially if they have made a deal with him (like Emma going to New York, finding his son, AND making his son talk to him in exchange for custody of Ashley’s baby—which, according to law, she would have had the right to custody even beyond the signing of any legal adoption documents). Once again, Colin’s acting choice was pure perfection, saying everything and nothing with the twitch of a muscle or the direction of his gaze.