Fire and Blood, by George R.R. Martin, pg 298-300
[The Lucamore Strong Scandal]
@horizon-verizon / horizon-verizon.tumblr.com
Fire and Blood, by George R.R. Martin, pg 298-300
[The Lucamore Strong Scandal]
“Three.” Saying it left a bitter taste in her mouth. “The cowards broke in on some weavers, freedwomen who had done no harm to anyone. All they did was make beautiful things. I have a tapestry they gave me hanging over my bed. The Sons of the Harpy broke their loom and raped them before slitting their throats.” (Dany IV ADWD)
When your opponent has no moral conscience; when your opponent is targeting not just soldiers/warriors (the Unsullied) but also innocent freedwomen, weavers, who are just trying to make an honest living with their artisanship; when your opponent engages in rape and murder of innocent freedwomen; how can you in any conscience say that 1) this kind of situation is peaceful and 2) that dealing nonviolently with such an opponent is possible?
How can you deal nonviolently with a group of people that uses wanton violence, including weaponized sexual violence, against civilians, in a so called time of peace? A militant insurgent reactionary group that destroys their businesses and then rapes these women before murdering them? In Rylona Rhee’s case, cutting off her fingers before murdering her in her own home? In Stalwart Shield’s case, butchering him when he was seeking companionship and healing in a brothel and having to target him as a group, feeding his genitalia to a goat before killing him?
What kind of peaceful land is it, when militant insurgent groups can terrorize oppressed people in such a manner, rape women and butcher soldiers off duty, and they are supported by the elite of the population, who feed them information (like the wineseller, or telling each of the Harpies exactly which freedmen are politically vocal or prosperous business wise)?
How could Adam Feldman ever have argued that the peace in Meereen was real? What kind of peace is it when freedmen and freedwomen are trying to live their lives, feed their children, make their crafts, play their music, fight for their rights, and they are butchered, raped, and tortured for doing so?
You lot talk a lot about Dany committing a human rights violation by sanctioning the torture of the wineseller’s daughters (and then ignore that she herself put a stop to it). What about the torture that the Sons of the Harpy engage in––feeding Stalwart Shield’s genitalia to a goat, cutting off Rylona Rhee’s fingers, raping weaver women?
What nonviolent way is there to properly get rid of a group like that and ensure lasting protections for the freedmen? Is there such a parallel in history where nonviolence has fully worked and shown longevity against an oppressive group?