mouthporn.net
#cw castration – @horizon-verizon on Tumblr
Avatar

editorialized torpedo

@horizon-verizon / horizon-verizon.tumblr.com

she/her -- ASoIaF Enthusiast -- (I will be changing the title of this blog frequently just because I want to)
Avatar
Near year’s end, a shameful revelation came to light that shocked both court and city. The amiable and well-loved Ser Lucamore Strong of the Kingsguard, a favorite of the smallfolk, was found to have been secretly wed, despite the vows that he had sworn as a White Sword. Worse, he had taken not one but three wives, keeping each woman ignorant of the other two and fathering no fewer than sixteen children on the three of them. In Flea Bottom and along the Street of Silk where whores and panders plied their trade, men and women of low birth and lower morals took a wicked pleasure in the fall of an anointed knight, and made bawdy japes about “Ser Lucamore the Lusty,” but no laughter was heard in the Red Keep. Jaehaerys and Alysanne had been especially fond of Lucamore Strong and were mortified to learn that he had played them both for fools. His brothers of the Kingsguard were even angrier. It was Ser Ryam Redwyne who discovered Ser Lucamore’s transgressions and brought them to the attention of the Lord Commander of the Kingsguard, who in turn brought them to the king. Speaking for his Sworn Brothers, Ser Gyles Morrigen declared that Strong had dishonored all they stood for, and requested that he be put to death. When dragged before the Iron Throne, Ser Lucamore fell to his knees, confessed his guilt, and begged the king for mercy. Jaehaerys might well have granted him same, but the errant knight made the fatal error of appending “for the sake of my wives and children” to his plea. As Septon Barth observed, this was tantamount to throwing his crimes in the king’s face. “When I rose against my uncle Maegor, two of his Kingsguard abandoned him to fight for me,” Jaehaerys responded. “They might well have believed they would be allowed to keep their white cloaks once I’d won, perhaps even be honored with lordships and a higher place at court. I sent them to the Wall instead. I wanted no oathbreakers around me, then or now. Ser Lucamore, you swore a sacred vow before gods and men to defend me and mine with your own life, to obey me, fight for me, die for me if need be. You also swore to take no wife, father no children, and remain chaste. If you could shrug aside the second vow so easily, why should I believe that you would honor the first?” Then Queen Alysanne spoke up, saying, “You made a mockery of your oaths as a knight of the Kingsguard, but those were not the only vows you broke. You dishonored your marriage vows as well, not once but thrice. None of these women are lawfully wed, so these children I see behind you are bastards one and all. They are the true innocents in this, ser. Your wives were ignorant of one another, I am told, but each of them must surely have known that you were a White Sword, a knight of the Kingsguard. To that extent they share your guilt, as does whatever drunken septon you found to marry you. For them some  mercy may be warranted, but for you...I will not have you near my lord, ser.” There was no more to be said. As the false knight’s wives and children wept or cursed or stood in silence, Jaehaerys commanded that Ser Lucamore be gelded forthwith, then clapped in irons and sent off to the Wall. “The Night’s Watch will require vows from you as well,” His Grace warned. “See that you keep them, or the next thing you lose shall be your head. Jaehaerys left it to his queen to deal with the three families. Alysanne decreed that Ser Lucamore’s sons might join their father on the Wall, if they wished. The two oldest boys chose to do so. The girls would be accepted as novices by the Faith, if that was their desire. Only one elected that path. The other children were to remain with their mothers. The first of the wives, with her children, was given over to the charge of Lucamore’s brother Bywin, who had been raised to be the Lord of Harrenhal not half a year earlier. The second wife and her offspring would go to Driftmark, to be fostered by Daemon Velaryon, Lord of the Tides. The third wife, whose children were the youngest (one still on her breast), would be sent down to Storm’s End, where Garon Baratheon and young Lord Boremund would see to their upbringing. None were ever again to call themselves Strong, the queen decreed; from this day they would bear the bastard names Rivers, Waters, and Storm. “For that gift, you may thank your father, that hollow knight.””

Fire and Blood, by George R.R. Martin, pg 298-300 

[The Lucamore Strong Scandal]

Avatar
“Three.” Saying it left a bitter taste in her mouth. “The cowards broke in on some weavers, freedwomen who had done no harm to anyone. All they did was make beautiful things. I have a tapestry they gave me hanging over my bed. The Sons of the Harpy broke their loom and raped them before slitting their throats.” (Dany IV ADWD)

When your opponent has no moral conscience; when your opponent is targeting not just soldiers/warriors (the Unsullied) but also innocent freedwomen, weavers, who are just trying to make an honest living with their artisanship; when your opponent engages in rape and murder of innocent freedwomen; how can you in any conscience say that 1) this kind of situation is peaceful and 2) that dealing nonviolently with such an opponent is possible?

How can you deal nonviolently with a group of people that uses wanton violence, including weaponized sexual violence, against civilians, in a so called time of peace? A militant insurgent reactionary group that destroys their businesses and then rapes these women before murdering them? In Rylona Rhee’s case, cutting off her fingers before murdering her in her own home? In Stalwart Shield’s case, butchering him when he was seeking companionship and healing in a brothel and having to target him as a group, feeding his genitalia to a goat before killing him? 

What kind of peaceful land is it, when militant insurgent groups can terrorize oppressed people in such a manner, rape women and butcher soldiers off duty, and they are supported by the elite of the population, who feed them information (like the wineseller, or telling each of the Harpies exactly which freedmen are politically vocal or prosperous business wise)? 

How could Adam Feldman ever have argued that the peace in Meereen was real? What kind of peace is it when freedmen and freedwomen are trying to live their lives, feed their children, make their crafts, play their music, fight for their rights, and they are butchered, raped, and tortured for doing so? 

You lot talk a lot about Dany committing a human rights violation by sanctioning the torture of the wineseller’s daughters (and then ignore that she herself put a stop to it). What about the torture that the Sons of the Harpy engage in––feeding Stalwart Shield’s genitalia to a goat, cutting off Rylona Rhee’s fingers, raping weaver women? 

What nonviolent way is there to properly get rid of a group like that and ensure lasting protections for the freedmen? Is there such a parallel in history where nonviolence has fully worked and shown longevity against an oppressive group? 

You are using an unsupported browser and things might not work as intended. Please make sure you're using the latest version of Chrome, Firefox, Safari, or Edge.
mouthporn.net