I’m the Bad Guy
I learned a lot from TV and movies. As a kid, I consumed all the requisite, decade-appropriate material. Every neon and pastel colored cartoon in the eighties to the moody teen dramas of the nineties. I was there for all of it. And the biggest lesson I learned was this: I’m the bad guy.
There were small, almost invisible ways this lesson came to me. She-Ra was full of characters designed to sell toys. Everyone looked so cool and it was clear by their color palettes and animal companions who was on which side. I liked purple more than pink and cats more than horses. Catra, in all her villain glory, was my favorite. It almost broke my heart when I realized she was supposed to lose.
I remember listening to Joan Jett and The Ramones in the car with my mom. So, when I watched Jem and the Holograms, I couldn’t wait for the Misfits to show up and play their pop-punk music. Forget that they were all-caps EVIL and always trying to mess up the plans of the pink-wearing, family-friendly pop princess Jerrica.
Seeing Ally Sheedy play Allison Reynolds, a goth girl in ratty Chuck Taylor sneakers, oversized sweater, and a nearly androgynous haircut in The Breakfast Club was amazing. She was painfully shy, just like me. She ate weird food, just like me. Until the end of the movie when I realized that her character arc was ending with Clair Standish (Molly Ringwald), the preppy, pretty, pink-wearing (again) prom queen, giving her a makeover to be more feminine and pretty. And the makeover worked. She had more confidence. She kissed the boy she liked. But I remember watching that movie and just thinking that she looked cold without her sweater. I wish I could say I felt betrayed, but I think, even then, I always knew that was how it was going to shake out. She’d have to become someone I couldn’t relate to anymore.
In the nineties, the characters I identified with started getting more arcs. Or maybe I was just old enough to watch more complicated shows. Still, though, my favorites were never good.
I fell in love with Drusilla (Juliet Landau) on Buffy: The Vampire Slayer. She had the same issue a lot of weird goth girls in media have. Hyper-femininity. I loved her, but I never wanted to be her the way I heard some people talk about their favorite characters. Spike (James Marsters) was closer. Leather jacket, punk rock, and dark eyeliner. He did eventually get a redemptive arc, but it came at the cost of his edge. He wore his leather coat less. Traded in his black and red for blue. His eyeliner went away. Drusilla was never quite redeemed, but it was made clear she should be pitied. She’d been tortured before becoming a vampire. She had trauma.
Nancy Downs (Fairuza Balk) of The Craft, in all her goth glory, was amazing. She had Spike’s edge and Drusilla’s love of the strange. But, in a movie about a group of lesser evils, she was the ultimate evil. During one of my many re-watches of the movie, I realized why I connected to her so much. And why she was the one who had to be defeated.
Each of the characters in The Craft wants something. Rochelle (Rachel True) wants racists to leave her alone, Bonnie (Neve Campbell) wants to get rid of her scars, Sarah (Robin Tunney) wants to be a part of the group, and Nancy wants…
There’s a scene in the movie where Nancy goes home. She lives in a trailer. There’s lots of shouting. She goes to her room to try to get away from everything, but there’s a leak in her roof that lets rain fall down on her in bed. The way she deals with it all it looks both normal and highly triggering.
The Craft isn’t a movie about heroes. No one really looks good by the end of the film, but Nancy is treated especially badly. Nancy, abused and traumatized and needing help, falls short of being able to stop when she’s finally given the power to get out of her situation. She is the ultimate bad guy that drives the other three to pull back and become the good guys. The good guys who smile and laugh while Nancy is literally tied up and sent to an insane asylum (I’m using that phrasing because that’s how we’re supposed to feel about it—it is not a mental health facility, she will not get better). It is shown as exactly what she deserves. Maybe even meant to be a little funny.
Every character I’ve ever felt represented me has been killed or become the bad guy. Often both. Marvel’s Loki, canonically bisexual and likely genderfluid, is a villain. A likeable villain, but still. Ursula in The Little Mermaid was based on the drag queen Divine. Queerness happens in villains far more often than in heroes. The discovery is usually made at a moment when the hero is physically close and vulnerable in some way. The antagonist says something to make it clear they would be totally down for some sexual shenanigans. It’s a sign of how depraved they are. How little they care for society’s structures and rules. It shows the audience how uncontrolled and wild the villain really is.
The first time I saw character who felt like me, who wasn’t on the wrong side or ultimately forced to change was in 2016. Holtzmann (Kate McKinnon) in Ghostbusters. I sat there, ugly crying during a cartoony fight scene because there was this androgynous, bisexual character. And she was allowed to not only be one of the good guys, but be a helpful, valued member of the team.
Reading Half Bad by Sally Green, a book about a magical war with a traumatized, bisexual boy in the main role, carved a path from my eyes to my chest. Seeing him become a hero while everyone around him continued to treat him like a villain felt like one of the greatest truths I’d ever encountered.
Here are three things about me I talk about a lot, but don’t often come out and say so very clearly. I have a history of abuse and trauma. I am bisexual. I am transgender.
And the gathering of powers that be, who control the stories we get to see have made sure I know a fourth thing: