Mistaken
Requests: “Request Matt falling for you but then realizes your a vampire 😐” (Credits to gif owners!) Sorry its so short!
You thought Stefan was lying when he told you that vampire and human relationships were difficult. He told you that it took a lot of effort to stay with Elena the way he was and you still wouldn't listen to him. As a result you hurt Matt, the only one you ever really loved. You were pretty sure he hated you and wanted nothing to do with you. Elena says that since Matt is the only one who doesn't know how to handle being the only human out of the group, he shelters himself away.
When Matt actually answered the phone after trying to get a hold of him all day. "Matt! Thank god you're okay-" You cradled your face with your hand. "I'm so sorry...About what happened. Look-" But Matt didn't respond as happily as you had hoped. He sounded stressed and disappointed.