mouthporn.net
#poor – @fathershane on Tumblr
Avatar

Fr. Shane Johnson

@fathershane / fathershane.tumblr.com

I'm Father Shane Johnson,a Catholic priest at St. Anthony of Padua Parish in the Bronx.
Avatar
Anonymous asked:

Dear Fr.,I have been talking to a friend who comes from a different denomination about the Prosperity Gospel. I know that it is unBiblical and I have tried to show them why but they rebuke whatever I say. Are there different types of the Prosperity gospel? I'm not too sure how to respond if this comes up again.

That's what the Brits would call a "rare bird": someone who can argue convincingly for the prosperity gospel. I'm sure that my understanding of it is a bit simplistic, but it seems to me that any one of the following (and more) refutes the doctrine that Jesus blesses believers with riches:

  • It totally flies in the face of the Beatitudes... Luke's version is mostly about the poor being blessed and the rich not.
  • The "anawim" (God's beloved poor) of the Old Testament make no sense in the Prosperity Gospel.
  • St. Paul is constantly going on about how he was proud to have worked by his own hands, having taken nothing from the people he evangelized.
  • "Silver and gold I do not have, but what I do have I give you" (Acts 3:6)... faith doesn't imply riches, but something deeper.
  • The riches we are promised are in Heaven, not here.
  • Jesus died without a single possession. They took it all.
  • Does martyrdom make any sense in the prosperity gospel?
  • Oh, and I have a vow of poverty. :-)

Just some random ideas. God bless!

- Father Shane

You are using an unsupported browser and things might not work as intended. Please make sure you're using the latest version of Chrome, Firefox, Safari, or Edge.
mouthporn.net