mouthporn.net
#confessions – @enlitment on Tumblr
Avatar

Vivre libre ou mourir

@enlitment / enlitment.tumblr.com

24 | she/her | obsessed with the French Revolution, Ancient Rome, and the Enlightenment | history, philosophy, lit, classics & 18th-century drama enthusiast | most likely haunted by Rousseau's ghost
Avatar
Anonymous asked:

I dont know if you already answered this question (I'm sorry if you did!) but, which JJ's book do you recommend for starters?

Hi, thank you for the ask. I don't think I've ever answered it publicly actually!

It depends entirely on what interests you:

1. The Social Contract/Du contrat social

-> start here if you want to pick up Rousseau because you're interested in the French Revolution/politics/political philosophy. It is probably his most famous work (along with Emile maybe)

It's surprisingly readable (and funny at times!), though if you expect a perfectly coherent and logical system, be prepared for disappointment. It also helps to know at least some basics (like the gist of Hobbes' or Locke's political philosophy), but don't worry if you don't, you're still understand most of it.

2. Letter to M. d'Alembert on Spectacles

-> start here if you want a genuinely fascinating insight into late 1700s misogyny. It's chilling how some of the arguments feel so contemporary. It's fairly short, and reads more like a ramble/angry twitter thread that just pulls you right in.

It's great to get your blood boiling, but not a great start if you want to like Rousseau. Oh, and if you read it alongside Confessions, the sheer level of cognitive disonance/denial it's simply delicious.

3. Confessions

-> start here if you want to learn about Rousseau's life. It won't necessarily give you the true facts, but it will offer you a fascinating insight into his mind.

It's one hell of a ride, but it's not all weird psychosexual wtf moments. You can learn a lot from it about what life was like in the 18th century, and about the (usually unspoken) social norms. One thing I loved was that it revealed how much power French women actually had in the society, though it wasn't immediately obvious.

Also, there are some passages in which he talks about his social anxiety and insecurities where I genuinely find myself sympathising with him.

I'm also sorry to say that I firmly believe that it's a fun read. It gets very, very frustrating at times, but the man could write.

4. Introducing Rousseau by Dave Robinson

-> Start here if you want a quick overview/something to hold onto before jumping straight in!

Yeah, it's an illustrated guide, it's a tiny book and it looks a bit daft, but I personally swear by it. It's a very quick and engaging read, but it represents his philosophy and his life fairly well from what I can tell.

Pictured here with my hand and the man himself:

Honourable Mentions:

5. Discourse on the Arts and Sciences -> start here if you want to start with a text that first made Rousseau famous/are keen to approach his works in a chronological order

6. Emile, or On Education -> I haven't read this one I'm afraid (though I now own it!), but it's one of his most influential works. If you're interested in the idea of childhood and education, this one's for you! (but prepare to be angry re: Education of Sophie I guess)

Hope this helps, and do let me know how you get on!
Avatar

Got my hands on Mary Shelley's 1815 Goodreads challenge!

It feels really exciting to have an opportunity to read it, but I also regret to inform you...

There's a lot of Voltaire as well though... Also I'm aware of her mother's thoughts on Rousseau (did read him but not a big fan of his view of women, surprise surprise). Not sure if Mary's are documented though!

Avatar

Today on documents of great historical importance (/s), I present my diary entry from June:

text: JJ still on my brain. Jeez. And they say women are complicated and hard to understand.

JJ had 'hysteria'*, because of course he had, but the milf power™**(combined with seeing a cool Roman bridge***) somehow cured him.

Only he came back and found out that Mme de Warens had acquired for herself a new boy-toy. Lmao.

-------------

* the translator really did use that word which I thought was interesting, because in all of the early modern resources, it seemed incredibly femme-coded (and it does make some sense, given the origin of the word...)

** not Mme de W mind you. Some lady he met during a coach journey to Paris with a sixteen-year old daughter

*** Pont du Gard. And honestly, kind of a mood:

Avatar
reblogged

Why did this review for a book (Is That a Fish in Your Ear) have to take me out back and shoot me

Avatar
enlitment

oh. oh god no. bad news, you might be getting haunted as well (I've seen it kept in the original French a couple of times in English texts discussing Rousseau and I'm like 90 % sure the main reason for it was that translating it would make the whole thing somehow even more uncomfortable)

Avatar
reblogged
Avatar
enlitment

also side note but there may or may not be something in Rousseau's Confessions that almost went down in Venice that would unfortunately make Danton marrying a 16-year-old feel super mild in comparison

yeah, not a great time for (especially lower class) women

It has been haunting me for a while now so just getting it out there I guess

Okay, okay, I'll stop being coy about it. But just a fair warning for treatment of girls and just a general 18th-century insanity.

The fact that nothing happens is honestly a huge relief, though as usual, JJ is being weirdly self-congratulatory for not being a ...

It's also worth noting though that just based on the way he writes about it, it sounds as if an arrangement like this (albeit maybe with a girl slightly older) would certainly not be something unheard of :(

Avatar

10 & 15 for the book ask 💞

Avatar

Thank you for the ask! ^^

10. Do you have a guilty fav?

Oh boy do I!

Rousseau's Confessions definitely fits that category to a t. I might as well come clean and admit how much I actually enjoyed reading at least the first few books (while also finding myself frustrated with JJ to the point of madness ofc - many, many times).

I would of course never go full Brissot, but I can't rule out a potential re-read in the future...

Apart from that, I also have a lot of complicated feelings about Chuck Palahniuk's books (probably most famous for Fight Club). No other author seem to oscillate between brilliant and absolutely atrocious as much as he does.

15. recommend and review a book:

It's been a while since I've read it, but I really liked Margaret Atwood's The Penelopiad!

I know the book market is currently overflowing with Greek myths retellings, but this one is one of the original ones and - at least for me - one of the good ones.

I felt like Atwood didn't sanitise Penelope's character but rather made her a complex, quite morally grey heroine. I enjoyed seeing the events of the Odyssey from her perspective more than say, that of Miller's Circe. The way she felt bitterly jealous of Helen, the few sweet moments which fleshed out her relationship with Odysseus, her interactions with Telemachus... Atwood's Penelope just somehow felt more like a human being.

I also loved how she made Penelope's 12 maids into a Greek chorus, utilised a lot of different genres throughout the book (including a 21st century academic lecture), and reinterpreted one often overlooked passage of The Odyssey in a fascinating new way. No spoilers, but just for that alone, it's worth a read!

Avatar
"And thus do we have Voltaire to thank (...) for being the catalyst of Rousseau's Confessions, one of the world's great autobiographies."

– from R. Pearson's Voltaire Almighty

So now you know who to blame!

Avatar
reblogged

Seriously though were people in the past just constantly giggling at the word “suck” being written with a long s like was that a thing do you think

Avatar
yeoldenews

I have a collection of these I keep in a folder called “I am an adult”.

John Donne found it funny at least

Avatar
enlitment

Oh the infamous flea poem! Perfect reasoning Donne, no notes

Also my humble contribution (does it count if it's a translation? I swear the translator did it on purpose):

(you'll never guess where it's from. it's a real mystery.)

Avatar
“When I see or hear of any act of injustice – whoever is the victim of it, and wherever it is committed – my heart kindles with rage, as if the effect of it recoiled upon myself.”

— Jean-Jacques Rousseau, Confessions

Avatar
enlitment

No that one's Rousseau!

He put five of his children to the orphanage to be exact. Didn't even bother to put monograms on them after the first one.

Fun fact: he went on to write a book on how to best raise children afterwards.

But don't worry, he lets you know that even though that wasn't a very nice thing to do, the real villains of the story are his friends for snitching on him.

You are using an unsupported browser and things might not work as intended. Please make sure you're using the latest version of Chrome, Firefox, Safari, or Edge.
mouthporn.net