bakery au where nicky works in a popular bakery that gets crazy lines around the holidays because they do themed cookies cakes treats etc and joe has the worst luck for craving something sweet on days that are either abnormally busy or are holidays (joe doesn’t notice this pattern; he thinks the bakery is just crazy busy everyday because they have good cookies) so he’ll wait in line for twenty minutes meanwhile nicky is behind the counter fighting for his life putting together all these insane holiday orders worth hundreds of dollars trying to prevent customers from fist fighting over cakes and then joe always appears for 0.5 seconds in the middle of the rush like i would like one cookie please :) whichever one you like the best :) and tips more than double the cost of the actual cookie so nicky starts giving him free extras and the first time he does it joe gets back in the line just to come back in and politely offer to pay because nicky accidentally gave him three cookies instead of one and nicky makes him take another cookie and insists it’s a perk of being a favorite customer before he has to turn away to prevent a middle aged mom from throwing a tantrum because they’re sold out of the sugar cookies she wants. joe finds this confusing bc the reason he tips so much is that he feels bad for only getting one little thing when everybody else seems to be leaving with huge bags but the hot bakery man is giving him free food so hey he’s not going to argue. he and nicky get onto a first name basis, even if they never have time to exchange more than a sentence or two. nicky somehow figures out that joe likes vanilla and buttery flavours more so than chocolate. it’s cool being a regular.
cut to one fateful valentine’s day that joe somehow has failed to realise is valentine’s day. he waits in the line, comes in and asks for a cookie. nicky charges him the cost of one cookie and then grabs three at random as per their usual exchange, which turn out to be sugar cookies iced to look like those valentine’s sweetheart candies. the first one says hey cutie, the second one says be mine, and the third one says what’s your number?
joe, a little confused but a lot flattered, scribbles his phone number and a little message with a winky face on his receipt and stuffs it into the tip jar with a bill. then he walks out of the bakery and goes about his day, wondering absently if anything will come of it, and if a baker would enjoy a first date where joe cooked him dinner.
it takes him 45 minutes to realise it’s valentine’s day. it takes 3 more for him to realise that nicky didn’t personalise those cookies just for him, and half a second more to decide he can never enter the bakery again, and in fact might have to leave the country.
at 6:07 that evening, seven minutes after the bakery has closed, when joe is on the way over to andy’s to lament the state of his life, he gets a text from an unknown number that says you are either the boldest man i’ve ever met in my life or the dumbest. when are you taking me out? xx - nicky