Abnormal Psych 2- Avoidance is Key
Author’s Note: This is a sequel to Psych 101.
Summary: Nothing is normal with John Winchester in the house. He’s charming, but rude, the most toxic of influences on both of his sons... and now he’s got his sights on Y/n.
Pairings: Sam x Dean, Dean x Reader, Sam x Reader, Sam x Dean x Reader,
Word count: 4721
Story Warnings: mentions of WINCEST, incest, Dom/sub dynamics , Dom!Sam, Switch!Dean, sub!Reader, John is a dick, some mentions of john being horrible to them when they were kids
~~~~
“Oh! John! It’s nice to meet you,” you said, forcing a smile despite the fact that you were incredibly perturbed by the sudden appearance of your soon-to-be father-in-law. “I-I didn’t know you were coming! I would have hired a maid to clean the place up or something.”
“What, you don’t clean?” John asked, smiling.
“She doesn’t really have a lot of time for cleaning, Dad,” Sam snapped. “None of us really do.”
“Calm down, Sammy, it was just a joke,” John dismissed as you pulled your hand away.
“It’s ‘Sam’,” Sam responded before moving to stand on Dean’s opposite side. “He didn’t tell anyone he was coming, so you wouldn’t have been able to do anything to prepare anyway, Y/n. None of us would have.”
“You boys really forgot how to take a surprise, huh?” John said with a laugh. “Dean called me up when you left California, told me about the new house and the special woman making him an honest man and as soon as I got done in Nashville, I wanted to come see the life you three are making for yourselves.” His hazel eyes focused on you and he crossed his arms over his chest. “I was tellin’ Dean a few minutes ago that it’s gonna get awkward in a while when you two get married and start a family and his kid brother’s still hanging onto the apron strings, ya know?”
Dean’s hand squeezed yours tighter and you squeezed back to reassure him. “We already are a family. The three of us are a family, John. Sam’s already my brother and when Dean and I get married, we’re not going to change a thing.”