An Open Letter to USA: Why You Should Renew Playing House
By Claire McCleskey
A show that feels as authentic as Playing House only comes around once in a blue moon. It’s almost impossible to watch an episode without believing, perhaps even wishing, you live in the small town of Pinebrook and hang out with Emma Crawford and Maggie Caruso on a regular basis.
The show feels real, the characters are relatable. While I can’t quite say my best friend has ever been pregnant, left by her husband, and I’ve decided to leave my high-paying job in China to move back to help her raise her child, I still see myself in them. It probably has something to do with the fact that the fabulously talented Lennon Parham and Jessica St. Clair are best friends in real life. Their relationship feels so genuine and honest. Emma’s struggle to adjust to life in her small hometown is one that anyone who grew up in, and left, a small town can relate to. From my personal experience, it seems like everyone who grew up in the suburbs is either an Emma—who leaves and feels trapped when returning—or a Mark—who is perfectly happy staying where he is. Playing House’s portrayal of what it’s like to return to a small town is the most realistic one on television.
Those are just a few of the reasons why, creatively, this show is unique. But television—for better or for worse—is a business. So, USA, you may be wondering what your incentive is to renew Playing House. Well first of all, you’re currently trying to diversify your programming. In fact, that’s why you picked up Playing House in the first place. Your motto is “Characters Welcome.” This show is, at its core, about characters. So Playing House manages to fit into your current programming nicely while still diversifying it. But this cast is the best thing you have going for you. Lennon Parham, Jessica St. Clair, Zach Woods, and Keegan-Michael Key are all names that will draw in a new audience for you. They’re highly regarded in the world of comedy, so if you’re trying to draw in a new crowd of comedy fans with your “Comedies Welcome” campaign, they’re your golden ticket. I would tune in to watch the four of them read the phone book.
So, USA, I know nobody asked for my opinion. I know you know a lot more about how this works than I do, but if you were to ask my opinion, I’d tell you that you’d be crazy not to renew Playing House.