The new teacher is flirting with him and Dean has no idea what to do. Well, he could stop bumbling about like an idiot and stand up for himself, but seeing as his brain won’t work that way, he’s out of options.
The guy’s good looking, don’t get him wrong, but he’s also…coming on very strong. Maybe that’s just Dean, where everyone comes on strong to him, but this guy is all up in his space and staring him down in a way that feels more uncomfortable than it should.
He says something about his classes, something about how sophomores are difficult, and pairs it with a laugh that’s far too breathy to be genuine. Dean nods along politely, kicking himself under his desk for letting this conversation go on as long as it has. He lets his eyes flick to the analog clock hanging on the wall and he realizes he’s only got 10 minutes until break is over. He’s got things to do and this brown haired fella who thinks he’s hot shit is taking up all his time.
“I should get some coffee,” Dean says, pushing away from his desk. Much to Dean’s dismay, the other teacher stands with him. At least he isn’t basically drooling on Dean’s desk anymore.
“I should too, may I join you?” His eyes are wide and his smile is soft and his hands are firmly planted in the back of his jean pockets. It would be cute if it wasn’t so try-hard. Dean caves with a groan and “helps” the other guy through the school as he plays up how lost he is. He’s miserable.
The dude keeps talking as Dean fills up the largest paper cup the cafeteria offers with black coffee. He continues to talk as he gets his own, going on about he just loves the way Dean has his room organized. There’s a large poster of the cover of Fahrenheit 451, matching ones for Dracula and Frankenstein and three large bookshelves. It’s thoroughly unimpressive. And even after Dean informs him that all his literature posters come from a publisher he contacts through the school, the new guy keeps talking, keeps asking questions. His dark hair falls in his face a couple times and the way he looks at Dean through his bangs and his eyelashes gets on his nerves. This is not a rom-com, it’s a high school. Everyone’s tired, Dean especially tired of this guy’s shit.
He almost leaves him in the dust as he trudges up a floor to his classroom. He’s got a class to teach and probably someone waiting for him. The guy says something about how he prefers his coffee a flat, boring brown color and Dean can’t help but think the description matches the man’s eyes.
Rounding the corner to room 213, he hears the first welcome piece of dialogue of the past twenty minutes. “Dr. Novak, are you sure you’re allowed to sit in his chair?” It’s the voice of 11th grader Patience Turner and the image that accompanies her question does not dissapoint. Cas is sitting there, twirling slowly around and around in his desk chair.
“Dr. Novak,” Dean says, strolling up to the desk, “I see you’ve made yourself at home in my chair, is there something you need?”
Cas just looks back up at him and says, “Your coffee preferably.” When Dean fits him with a look he says, “What? The coffee at home just isn’t the same.” Dean hands the cup over.
A small, impatient, cough disrupts their moment and Dean turns from Cas to the other teacher.
“Oh, hello,” Cas says, standing immediately in an effort to be polite, but Dean can see his face written with confusion. “I’m Dr. Novak, I teach freshman biology and junior chem.” He extends a hand that is taken with far too much hesitation for Dean’s taste.
The guy gives a slow nod, turns to Dean and says, “I prefer the humanities.” And then he winks. At Dean. In front of Cas. Instead of socking the guy in the jaw, Dean stares at him, open-mouthed.
Beside him, Cas is the one to react with a scoff and a glare. The guy has moved on though, deciding to once again lay his hands on Dean’s desk, touching all of the little things he’s placed there. He’s lucky Dean is pressed close to Cas on the opposite side of the desk or his invasion of privacy would be rewarded with a severely broken nose.
Dean and Cas just stare as the fingers ghost across the trinkets and eventually land on the little flag in his pencil jar. One of the man’s thimbas runs across the blue, pink, and purple stripes and Dean feels himself tense.
“This is wonderful.” Dean is still tense because of the presence, but less so not that he won’t be attacked for his sexuality. “It’s good to see someone so proud of themselves in a place like this.” In his peripherals, Dean sees Cas squint and Dean watches as the man beige him teeters on the edge of crossing a line. “I wish I could be so forward with my…emotions.” He looks Dean dead in the eyes with a sickly sweet smile and it’s so obviously not about pride that Dean wants to hurl.
Cas takes a surprised breath in that’s covered by the first bell. The other teacher is pulled out of his ploy and he rights the things he touched before looking at Dean one final time. “It was good getting to know you, Mr. Winchester.”
Dean laughs lightly as he turns away but as he turns to look at Cas he sees his jaw has tightened. Cas waits one more second before he blurts, “Doctor.” Dean drops his head to his hands, flustered by Cas’ need to correct the mistake.
“I’m sorry?” The guy asks. He takes a wary step into the class.
“It’s Dr. Winchester,” Cas explains. He points to one of the shelving units where Dean’s framed PhD sits. “It’s in contemporary literature. You would have known that if you’d tried to get to know him instead of get him home with you.” His voice is low and almost angry and Dean takes that chance to step in.
“Cas, honey,” he moves to stand between the two men, “not right now.”
“You’re my husband, Dean, I can’t just-“
“I know, but he’s new, give him a break.”
Cas sighs heavily and glares from Dean to the other teacher and back again. “There’s a photo of me on your desk and a ring on your finger, if he’s that stupid, he shouldn’t be teaching.” Cas says the last bit a little louder than necessary and Dean catches a flash of blush by the doorway when he turns around to check.
Dean waves the guy off, and turns back to Cas. “Problem solved.” To Cas’ disbelieving look he says, “I think he’s too scared of you to talk to me again, babe.”
Cas raises an impressed eyebrow and begins to walk away. He takes three steps before he turns to kiss Dean hard on the lips. Dean sighs into the kiss but his brain doesn’t let him forget about the class full of people. “Students, Cas, students.”
Cas adresses them, “My apologies.”
“Don’t apologize to me!” Krissy shouts from the front of the class. She gets two twin glares from her AP English and ex-chemistry teachers.
“Go to class, Cas,” Dean says with a light push. He watches Cas walk out and gives him a tiny wave of goodbye when he reaches the door.
He plucks his book from the top of his desk and strides to the front of the room, invigorated and free from the flirty presence of the other teacher. “Lets turn to chapter 29 in our copies of Anna Karenina.” Setting the book down, he writes on the board, Don’t mess with married people.
“Nice, Dr. Winchester,” Alex says with a little laugh.
“You can say ‘mister’. Cas is the only one who cares.”
She looks up again. “You mean Dr. Novak?”
“No, I mean Cas, and when you marry him, you can call him that too.”