Dark!13 in RotD
Now that we’ve all had a couple of days to process, can we talk about how dark the Doctor′s solution to her Dalek problem really was? Hear me out:
1: The “I’m the Doctor” speech. The realisation that being the Doctor means defeating Daleks. Yes, yes that’s what the Doctor does but it’s not the only thing. After having had all that time struggling with her identity, trying to figure out what she is, that’s a really unsettling realisation to come to. After regeneration, she didn’t know who she was either. And back then, she said the one thing she was sure of is that when people need help, she’d never refuse. Whatever happened to “I’m just a traveller.“?
She is defining herself through being the main predator of the most deadly creature in the universe. And there is no doubt in her expression, just silent icy fury.
2: She is toying with and taunting the Daleks. Yes, it is to lure them into a trap but she’s having too much fun. Look at her baring her teeth at them like a predator. She already knows she’s won and she’s enjoying the kill.
3: What she actually does to the Daleks… she doesn’t just trick them or gets rid of them, no she wipes them out without second thoughts. No remorse. Yes, it’s what the Doctor does, they have killed so many Daleks. But remember when the Doctor didn’t kill Davros? When they had the chance to never have the Daleks happen at all if he refused to save their creator? And yet they did because that’s what the Doctor does. Helping people in need, even when they grow up to become their enemies. The 12th Doctor had come such a long way.
4: The way she killed the Daleks: By destroying a TARDIS. This is the worst thing of all, the disregard for the TARDIS. Think of the close relationship she has with her TARDIS, the ways in which it is sentient and they are companions to each other. Look at these lines from “Twelve Angels Weeping”. The spare TARDIS is sentient too and the Doctor has no second thoughts about that. Just wipes it out of existence.
“The name I chose is “The Doctor“. The name you chose is like a promise you make.“
“Basic stuff first: Never be cruel, never be cowardly. (…) Remember, hate is always foolish, and love is always wise. Always try to be nice but never fail to be kind.“
“Doctor. The word for healer and wise man across the universe. We get that word from you, you know. But if you carry on the way you are, what might that word come to mean? To the people of the Gamma Forests, the word “doctor” means “mighty warrior.“
Where do we go from here? What will “Doctor” come to mean?