The whumper had quickly gotten tired of the whumpee and their pleading. They stopped talking to them, stopped mocking and threatening them. They only tortured them.
Somehow, the silence was worse.
It was just a few words that broke it, all of them commands. Eat. Stand. Kneel. Sleep. Don’t sleep.
The last one was the worst by far. It didn’t refer to a kitchen table -they weren’t allowed to sit at that one- but a metallic torture table. The whumpee had to lay on it as soon as they heard that word, and from that moment on, everything was pain.
They were tortured for hours on that table. The whumper used to talk to them, sometimes to explain exactly what they were going to do so they could watch the whumpee despair as they squirmed in immovable bonds.
But now it was just their own screams they heard. And when the whumper got sick of them, too, they gagged the whumpee. And then it was only silence, but for the sound of the whumper’s tools and the muffled cries that the gag couldn’t completely silence.
After rescuing and taking them in, the caretaker was the first person to talk to them. Really talk to them. About the whumpee’s injuries, the weather, some book. They didn’t like the silence any more than the whumpee did. Or perhaps they could sense the whumpee’s unease in a completely quiet room.
Soon, the whumpee began to speak, too. It was always just a few brief words, but the caretaker would still smile and praise them for it every time.
And then the whumpee would speak more. They were even beginning to enjoy talking to the caretaker. Every time they rubbed their shoulder lightly and said “keep it up!” the whumpee promised themselves they would keep it up.
It was all so great, like a dream. They should have known that they’d have to wake up, eventually.
“I brought your favorite!” the caretaker called from the door while they removed their shoes with one hand, a plastic bag in the other. “You just sit down at the table, I’ll-”
They were cut off by a loud noise.
Rushing to the kitchen, they found the whumpee standing there, completely still.
They had been washing the dishes at the time, after insisting that they didn’t want to sit in their room all day anymore, they wanted to be useful too.
Their hands were bloody, and there was a broken plate in the sink, but the whumpee’s eyes were fixed on the caretaker.
“You’re bleeding,” the caretaker said with a frown, and took a step forward.
The whumpee flinched and moved away, their back finding the wall.
“[Name]? What’s wrong?” the caretaker asked, stopping in their tracks.
The whumpee slid down the wall and hugged their knees, doing their best to make their thin body look even smaller. Blood smeared their pants as they pressed their palms against the light-colored fabric.
That word did not match the caretaker’s sweet, oh so very sweet and gentle voice, and yet the memories wouldn’t stop. They could see them, the whumper, like they were right in front of them, getting closer now, too close, they could see them and, and that table–
“N- No, don’t…” the whumpee whispered. “I’m sorry, I’m so sorry! Please…”
They knew they weren’t supposed to speak, and they were only making this worse, but they couldn’t help it. The caretaker had kept telling them to speak. They could finally hold a proper conversation, and they enjoyed talking to the caretaker, why did they have to stop now?
Why did they have to stop again?
The caretaker watched them silently, their mouth wide open in shock, but useless. They couldn’t think of anything to say, let alone utter it.
“I’ll be nice this time, I promise! I’ll be good, and I- I won’t call you by your first name again,” the whumpee said in a trembling voice.
It had been a real struggle to convince the whumpee that it was okay to call them by their name and without honorifics. The caretaker hadn’t realized that it still bothered the whumpee this much.
“And I- I’ll sleep on the floor, like I’m supposed to, and I won’t ask you for food again, I… I’ll do whatever you say, just please, please don't–”
The caretaker took their hand, and only then did the whumpee realize that they had approached them and were now crouched on the floor next to them.
“Don’t what?” the caretaker asked quietly, feeling stupid and utterly useless. “[Name], what did I say?”
“I’m sorry,” the whumpee said, mistaking the caretaker’s question for impatience and shakily getting back on their feet. “I’ll- I’ll get to the table. I’m sorry.”
The caretaker also stood. “You don’t have to, if you don’t want to…” they said with a frown, trying to keep their tone as gentle as possible.
The whumpee looked like they could barely hear them by now. Their whole body was trembling violently, and the caretaker still had no idea why.
“Sh- Should I get on the… the kitchen table?” they questioned quietly.
They didn’t want to be tortured. And they didn’t want to be tortured by the caretaker of all people. They had promised they wouldn’t hurt them, but the whumpee should have known it was all a lie. It was their fault, they should have known.
For some reason, the whumpee still couldn’t bring themselves to hate them. They owed the caretaker way too much for that…
“You can just sit down on the chair, if you don’t mind,” the caretaker muttered, still trying to figure out what it was they had done wrong.
The whumpee still looked like they were lost in their own head. Their lips parted, and there was a pause before they whispered, “May I please ask what I am being punished for?”
The caretaker blinked. “What?”
“So that I’ll know not to do it again,” the whumpee said.
They felt miserable asking that, but they had to know. The whumper had always made sure they knew what they were punished for. Even if they were punishing the whumpee on a whim, the whumper still told them.
But the caretaker wasn’t like the whumper. Surely they wouldn’t punish the whumpee without a reason. The whumpee had to know what it was, so that they could make sure they wouldn’t do it again, ever.
And maybe if it didn’t happen again after today, they could just forget about it and keep living with the caretaker in this beautiful dream, as if nothing had ever happened…
“What do you mean?” the caretaker asked. “[Name], you haven’t done anything wrong! I only asked you to sit down so we could eat.”
The whumpee looked up at them, clearly confused. “Really?”
What else could they possibly have meant when they said…
“I won’t be tortured?” the whumpee murmured warily in obvious disbelief.
“Oh. Oh. Oh, god, [Name], no!”
The whumpee flinched at the their tone, but the caretaker couldn’t stop. “How could you think that I would ever, ever lay a single hand on you?!”
The whumpee shivered and slid down the wall again, as if their legs couldn’t hold their weight anymore. They curled up into a ball and apologized desperately, “I- I’m sorry, I didn’t-”
The caretaker cut them off by pulling them into an embrace. The whumpee panicked and struggled at first, but then finally surrendered to it as the warmth of the caretaker’s arms overpowered their fear of being hurt.
“It’s okay. You’re safe now,” the caretaker whispered, rubbing the whumpee’s back soothingly. “When I took you in, I promised I’d keep you safe, didn’t I?”
The whumpee nodded mutely against the caretaker’s shoulder.
“I’m not going to hurt you, ever. And neither is anyone else. I’ll make sure of that.”
The whumpee nodded again.
“And you don’t have to call me anything but [Name], understand?”
Another nod. “I understand.”
“Good. Now, are you hungry? If you don’t like eating at… in the kitchen, let’s eat on your bed, okay?”
I’ll be allowed to eat, even after all this…
“It’s fine,” the whumpee muttered, their eyes finally focusing on the caretaker. “The t- t… the t- table’s fine.”
“No, that’s okay. You can go upstairs and get comfortable, I’ll bring trays.” The caretaker smiled. “I got you your favorite from that place we ordered from the other day.”
They stood up and offered the whumpee their hand.
“O- Okay,” the whumpee said, getting back on their feet with the caretaker’s help. “Th- Thank you, [Name].”
Once the table was out of their sight and they were sitting safely on their bed, the caretaker sitting across from them and making cheerful talk about this and that, the whumpee felt like they could finally breathe again.
Maybe this was more than just a dream, after all.