Chloe vs Marinette: The Only Comparison That Matters
So, a lot of discourse has been going around about things that people blame Marinette for and how she’s “just as bad as Chloe”, and since people like to bring in irrelevant information about certain villains that no one even cares about, we’re going to be crystal fucking clear here, mmkay? I’m gonna cross all my ts and dot my is and give to you all the only Chloe and Marinette comparison post that matters.
We’re also going to focus on what actually happened and not speculate or worry about what could have been, but just focus on the facts as we have them. The names below are of episodes which just so happen to be named after akumas. I stg if someone reblogs this and says a peep about how Hawkmoth is the only one to cause akumas, I will have an aneurism. besides if we’re going to be anal about it, at least be an intellectual and blame the writers of the show because they literally created this and made it all happen so
We aren’t talking about akumas right now. We are talking about harm that people say Marinette caused and whether or not she actually was the one to cause said harm, and if she truly is “just as bad as Chloe” since people like to apparently use her to justify their liking of Chloe by dragging an innocent character down to her level instead of just focusing on the qualities Chloe has shown that prove she isn’t as bad as most people make her out to be, but that’s salt for another post.
So, let’s take a look at all of the things people are blaming on Marinette and decide what she should actually be blamed for vs all of the things Chloe has done. I warn you: This is a very long ride, so buckle your seatbelts.
Antibug: This episode is one that still continues to irritate me to this day. Firstly, every character in the class gets an episode named after their akuma except Sabrina because she once again has to be overshadowed by Chloe. But that’s neither here nor there. People blame Marinette/Ladybug and say she was in the wrong for not believing Chloe when she was just trying to help, even the show calls her on this and makes it out to be her fault, but honestly that’s kind of a load of bullshit, and Chat Noir of all people should know that Chloe is very flawed and be able to recognize that, yes, she did just lie to them.
What do we know about Marinette? 1. She’s very serious about doing her job, and 2. she hates liars. In this episode, we have Chloe, not only lying straight to her face, but also inhibiting her from doing her job. She and Chat Noir are literally in the middle of fighting, and Chloe is doing nothing but getting in the way and putting herself in danger, forcing Ladybug to then have to protect her on top of fighting. The fact that Chloe was trying to be truthful and helpful the second time is irrelevant. All Ladybug knows is that she previously lied to them and that she’s preventing her from doing her job. She’s not an expert lie detector. She had no way of knowing whether or not Chloe was being honest or if she was even right until it became relevant.
The problem in this scenario is Chloe’s pride and her refusal to admit to her misdeeds. She knows good and well that she withheld information, but she got pissed because Ladybug called her on it. -Which brings up another point, can we talk about how creepy it is that Chloe can access the security cameras and just straight up spy on people?- Ladybug executed fair judgment in this episode, and it’s not fair for the fandom to criticize her for not listening to someone who lied to her not five minutes before.