posts about the alt-right pipeline being compassionate towards young men while radical leftists shun and shame them are not fucking saying "the men are becoming violent because feminists are too mean!" and if that is your takeaway you need to get off tumblr until you've better honed your critical thinking skills.
those posts are talking about how effective the language and approach you take in your activism can be. this is literally cult deprogramming 101. if someone is being taken in by a violent or dangerous group, that violent or dangerous group is usually offering them compassion and solace while working hard to convince them everyone else in the world is their enemy. you are under no obligation to coddle or act compassionate toward these men and their violent ideologies, but if you have the means to try, it is something that you can do to make a tangible difference.
radicalized people are often only one loving friend or family member or external voice away from being de-radicalized. of course that is not always the case, but it very often is. a lot of y'all rightfully understand that you do not carry the burden of being that voice, but a lot of y'all also have a lot of internalized ideas about morals and punitive justice and have simply written off these people as deserving of only the worst and not worth saving.
ten years ago, my grandmother was a fox news watching republican who voted red in every election and very well could have fallen down the qanon rabbit hole if not for me and her daughter challenging her compassionately, walking her through hypotheticals that validated her feelings & proving why they were false, & being patient with her despite our extreme division in political ideology. it was frustrating fucking work! but i decided i wanted to do it, because i could see the horizon and i could see me making a difference!
"misogynists have been saying feminists are too mean for years, get new material" that is not the fucking POINT. the point is that you, feminist, can be the compassionate voice that guides your brother, your father, your cousin, your grandfather away from fucking becoming or staying a nazi. you can show them compassion and companionship. you can be the woman they think of when their alt-right bros try to convince them that women are the enemy. and you can choose to crystallize that image of yourself so wholly in their mind's eye as worth protecting that they may very well choose to reject those harmful ideas.
it's not saying you HAVE to do it! it's saying you CAN do it! don't you 'firebomb a walmart' people all love taking change into your own hands? where the fuck is that energy right now, huh?
i saw this right after and OP turned off reblogs but LITERALLY!!! LITERALLY.
i know the punitive justice obsessed "kill all abusers" ass catholics on this fucking website don't want to hear shit like this but love is literally the answer. fix your heart or die
I willn always think about how a couple years back i, in begrudgingly helping the obnoxious kids in my science class with their homework to just get the class back on schedule, ended up positioning myself as Nerd With The Right Answers. this ended interestingly because when we get to the section of bio where we go over intersex people and i say "lmk if you have any questions on the homework", *they actually trusted me enough to express their confusion and expect a real answer*. Now, did i actually get them to understand fully? No, they couldn't get past their "biology says there's only two genders" cult programming. But the seed is there and the progress was made and the next time this concept is introduced to them, maybe by someone who used to be in the alt-right and knows their talking points and can specifically refute it, they will be open to understanding.
being the Nerd With The Right Answers was interesting because i was definitely being used, i am pretty sure i was mocked behind my back by them and i only helped because my teacher was overworked and the curriculum was so boring i had nothing else to so except explain what an atom is to a whole grown 17 year old, but it put me in the position to do some good cult deprogramming. One time a kid asked me "why do you wear a mask if covid isn't real" and i was like "not even gonna talk about the covid thing but i personally wear a mask because im immunocompromised so if i get a cold i might end up in the er and that's really scary for me" which, didn't challenge what theyd been told about the existence of covid but I'll be damned if the next time they meet someone wearing a mask they hesitate before harassing them.
Deprogramming extremism is difficult, it requires repeated reinforcement, politeness to people who don't deserve it, and sometimes personal connections with bigots and you are totally valid to feel uncomfortable with these things. If you can at the bare minimum say stuff like "no i don't want to sit with you because you said you hate me and i am respecting your very obvious desire for space from me" instead of "no i don't want to sit with you because you're a homophobe" it leaves the protective barriers down for someone else who has the energy to field the nonsense questions