To get on a rant for a second, I’m legitimately so angered as a Jewish person at the prevalence of “X fictional group or character is clearly a Nazi!” at characters that are not, in fact, members or supporters of the National Socialist German Workers’ Party/exterminating the Jewish population. Seriously, you may think you’re helping us out, but your “Kylo Ren and the First Order are literally Nazis! And liking them makes you a Nazi!”, “if you like any Death Eaters, you’re a Nazi apologist!”, “fans of X fictional oppressive regime’s characters are all promoting Nazism!” takes are not hot, and completely misinterpret Nazism and why it’s so insidious. To equate an ideology that killed millions of my relatives with Karen writing Kylo x Reader smut, to equate the suffering of so many human beings with “xxXSlytherinBabyXxx”’s Snape whump H/C fic doesn’t just trivialise Nazism, it’s outright fucking insulting (both to me and to fans who aren’t Jewish) and you seriously need to stop. I’ve not yet even touched on how patronising it is for goyim to tell Jewish fans they’re Nazis/Nazi sympathisers for writing villain redemption arcs, or for writing villains at all, because that would take all day! Using Nazi aesthetic parallels to make your fictional evil dictatorship seem more imposing is not the same as actually making them fucking Nazis.
End rant.
*comes back a year later*
Pointing out how many fictional dictatorships/fascist regimes are styled in the way of their real world counterparts, talking about how characters can be coded as obvious fascists/authoritarians, talking about how the Empire from SW is clearly using an obviously WWII Nazi Germany aesthetic, how the Death Eaters wear hooded robes and are obviously the magic version of white supremacists: fine, valid, I’m with you there, Nazis are vile human beings so making your villains look like Nazis is an easy way to imprint the whole part where they’re villains on your audience
SO IF YOU LIKE THESE VILLAINS’ CHARACTERS, WANT REDEMPTION FOR THEM, ARE INTERESTED IN THEIR ARC/NARRATIVE, OR JUST THINK THEY’RE COOL BAD GUYS YOU’RE A NAZI APOLOGIST AND YOU LOVE LICKING FASCIST BOOTS: absolutely, from the bottom of my heart, 100% completely, fuck you :)))
To be clear: saying this character and organisation is styled after a fascist regime and has a recognisable fascist regime aesthetic is fine. Implying that makes them LITERALLY THE SAME AS NAZIS and people who like them NAZI APOLOGISTS is not.
Also, like, how patronising and infantilising can you be in your insults? You know that people doing meta and fic on this or that villain aren’t even the edgelords who appropriate fascist symbolism because they think it makes them look cool that are the most insensitive (or at risk of apologism) here?
Like, do you honestly think strolling around in Stormtrooper gear is the same as wearing an SS uniform? That wearing a morsmordre t-shirt is the same as wearing a Swastika? There’s a disconnect here, because they’re cartoon villains, and Nazis are NOT.
Nazis are real. They may have absurd and grandiose visions of world domination that seem as laughable as Voldemort strolling around barefoot in black silk, but they’re not harmless cartoons, and they have a real death count. The Death Eaters and the Empire and the First Order are fake organisations who haven’t actually killed anyone because killing a fictional character is not actual murder. Slaughtering the Jedi is not real genocide. Killing the Muggleborns is not the Holocaust. They’re meant to invoke the same tone of eugenics, racism, and fascism, but they are not one-to-one equals, because one advocates for the death of REAL HUMANS, and the others advocate for the death of people with magical powers, who aren’t just fictional, but an actual, literal impossibility under the laws of physics. Being a fan of Darth Sidious is not like Stanning Adolf Hitler. Darth Sidious shoots lighting out of his hands and hates the space druids with the blue and green laser swords. Hitler ran death camps.
Don’t fucking trivialise Nazis and their crimes against humanity by equating them to the fucking “dewit” wrinkle man or the guy who tried to eat a unicorn.
*casually throws this post back because it’s relevant*
Aaaaaaand again
Again.jpg