I know that Ram V’s “Gotham Nocturne” isn’t for everyone, nor is it without flaws, but I still didn’t know how to deal with this criticism of the latest issue:
Putting aside how he apparently doesn’t understand the actual plot from the fact that he thinks it’s just about “Gotham vs werewolves” for some reason, I can’t get over this idea that Batman can’t or wouldn’t ever work with the likes of Mr Freeze and ESPECIALLY Harvey. Every other interaction between Batman and these two has Batman pleading “LET ME HELP YOU!” He CARES for them, and having them on his side even for a little while is a small triumph for Bruce and his hope for these men to turn their lives around!
And also, “Batman is ok working with murderers now?” JASON TODD, DUDE. Not to mention that in the pages of this very run of Detective Comics, Batman has worked alongside Harvey Dent TWICE, first in James Robinson’s “Deface the Face” and then in Peter Tomasi’s “Ugly Heart!” This isn’t a random, out-of-character choice for Batman, you just don’t read the comics!
And like, even if the story WAS just “Batman teams up with the rogues to fight werewolves,” why would anyone find that “dumb”?! That’s AWESOME! What kind of weirdo wouldn’t want to read that?!
It’s like, okay, I know this storyline isn’t going to be for all tastes. It’s an arthouse film epic of Gotham City as a whole, not the usual fan-friendly samey stuff about Batman and the Joker that’s tying into DC’s latest overblown event. It’s weird and different and definitely not for all tastes, plus its sprawling nature and ambitious themes can come off as incomprehensible and pretentious to anyone who’s not engaging with the story. I get all that.
But if you can’t get on board because it has Batman teaming up with two of his best tragic, tormented rogues, leading to Harvey fighting one (1) werewolf, I fundamentally just do not get you.