I get into Cohen's house and fine Eli while Cohen's not home.
I tell Eli his new owner is pissed at how jumpy he is. That he's useless and a massive burdon.
If Eli tells Cohen about my visit then I find out (anon magic?) and return with a whip to teach him a lesson in keeping his mouth shut.
Anyways, have fun and have a good day!
Eli doesn't believe you, but the anxiety over the interaction still becomes too much very quickly. Within a day of Cohen arriving home again, he tells him about what happened in search of reassurance and clarification.
Despite the new security measures put in place to stop people from breaking in again, you succeed. He is whipped over and over again for what feels like hours, leaving angry scars on his back and blood oozing from them. He cries, begging you to show him some mercy. He didn't know he'd get into trouble.
Cohen can see what's happened to him, but Eli still refuses to explain. He's too scared. Eventually, however, he breaks down and tells him everything.
That night, Cohen leaves to hunt you down.